Global identity concerns

Access & Identity Management Handbook 2015 Access Control & Identity Management

Being part of the identity industry globally, it can be a real eye-opener to see how the concerns and priorities change every few hundred kilometres. The pun on its connection to the technology of iris recognition is entirely unintended, though. From India, where millions of individuals enthusiastically queue up to provide their biometrics to a national database like Aadhaar, to Europe where data protection and privacy laws make it almost impossible to store, share or compare individual data, it becomes apparent that various countries and regions apply different yardsticks on this particular topic. But nobody is perfect.

Sanjay Dharwadker.
Sanjay Dharwadker.

The USA largely leaves the nitty-gritties to the private sector after providing overall guidelines that essentially go back to the Clinton–Gore administration. In recent years, the pitfalls of this particular approach have been more than exposed. In Europe, on the other hand, individual data protection and privacy continue to be governed by a two-decade-old directive, known as the 95/46/EC.

This is based on the European Union privacy and human rights law, which in turn draws itself from the essence of the European convention on human rights – article 8. While this directive is followed by and large across Europe as well considered as a model by countries in other regions, it has not been passed as law even in most of the European Union member countries. This situation is likely to change with the introduction of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in 2016, which is recommended to automatically become law in each of the member countries at the end of three years, that is by 2019.

In India for example, despite the records of over 900 million individuals being stored in a central repository, there is no data privacy law, and any potential misuse of data is protected only by an ad hoc Supreme Court directive. Even the agency administering the program – the Unique Identity Authority of India (UIDAI) is yet to be provided with legal status, and a corresponding law still needs to be enacted by the national parliament and also, a full constitutional bench is to be convened to determine issues such as how data protection and privacy are linked to the fundamental rights and directive principles enshrined in the nation’s constitution. In South Africa, similar provisions fall under the Protection of Personal Information (POPI) Act, which has been debated extensively during the last few years during which time, it has been enacted.

Globally, such variations in laws, directives and practices form a complex web around how technologies are deployed for various purposes by authorities and organisations for the purpose of security, welfare and the determination of legal identity. These also form, in some way, the basis of the age-old social-contract between the state and the individual.

In most cases, the immediate concerns and thus the local contexts are apparent: in South Africa it is having secure building environments – offices, homes and even public spaces that are enclosed in buildings such as shopping malls. In Europe the concept of 'gate' is pushed to the national boundary, thus giving rise to phenomena such as asylum seeking and refugee interspersed with temporal singularities such as statelessness. In India it is simpler concerns of providing access to food security irrespective of origin, but possibly exposing yourself to the rough and tumble of the country’s slum politics.

Is security then, as much a cultural and civilisational construct? It seems to require us to a priori define the ‘other’ and then building borders in between. No matter how we define it, we do not seem to eliminate from it the sense of discrimination and exploitation that often accompanies it. Our statesmen too have warned us throughout history that all this is often as much a problem of the mind.

What is disturbing is that today it is beginning to draw lines that divide humanity more decisively than ever before. Firstly, into those whose identities we can take for granted due to the numerous material attachments – bank accounts, jobs, businesses, tax records and mobile devices. On the other hand, there are the 'others' who may not even be afforded the luxury of a birth record. Linked to this are the issues of perennial impoverishment due to gender, child trafficking and other evils that continue to haunt us worldwide.

Can these twain ever meet? Is it all in our minds, or does it need us to manage all this in ways that we are yet to discover? This core issue perhaps requires more of our attention in coming times.

Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Turnstar ramps up countermeasures
Turnstar Systems Editor's Choice Access Control & Identity Management News Products
Turnstar has developed and patented an early warning and deterrent system which will alert security, and anyone nearby, of any attempt to place ramps over the raised spikes.

Suprema integrates biometric access control with Genetec
Suprema News CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring Access Control & Identity Management
Suprema has announced the successful integration of its biometric access control products with Genetec Security Center, a unified security platform that connects security systems, sensors and data in a single intuitive interface.

IDEMIA South Africa achieves level 1 B-BBEE status
IDEMIA News Access Control & Identity Management
As part of the action plan to improve its status to Level 1, IDEMIA now works with over 40 black-owned local suppliers, representing over 30% of IDEMIA’s local suppliers.

Suprema no. 1 in the global biometric market excluding China
Suprema News Access Control & Identity Management
According to the latest report by Omdia, a global market research firm, Suprema ranks first in global market share, excluding China, in the field of biometric readers.

Dahua and Yeastar PBX-intercom integration
Dahua Technology South Africa News Access Control & Identity Management
Dahua Technology and Yeastar announced their new ECO partnership on PBX-intercom integration to provide a comprehensive and unified communication solution for small- and medium-sized enterprises.

Traka launches experience centres
News Access Control & Identity Management
Traka launches inaugural Experience Centres in Australia and South Africa; aims to drive continuous collaboration and innovation.

New platform for keyless access
Access Control & Identity Management
The new ABLOY CUMULUS platform for keyless access combines locking hardware with secure access and management applications in a single ecosystem with a risk-free, integrated cloud service.

The importance of staying up to date
Access Control & Identity Management Government and Parastatal (Industry)
Africa’s cyber threat landscape is constantly evolving, with government’s facing a range of digital threats from espionage, critical infrastructure sabotage, organised crime and combat innovation.

Dynamic Drop Arm Barrier
Turnstar Systems Access Control & Identity Management
Suited to medium-volume access and medium-level security applications such as office reception areas, health clubs, universities and libraries, the Dynamic Drop Arm Barrier also allows special needs access.

Automatic tyre spike industrial vehicle barrier
Turnstar Systems Access Control & Identity Management
The Turnstar Velocity Raptor automatic tyre spike industrial barrier, with SwiftDrive technology, is aimed at high-volume and high-security access applications such as parkades, shopping centres, residential estates and airports.