The poor quality of security consultants

February 2002 News & Events

Much has been written, after the horror of last September's terror attacks in America, that the security industry failed the public - in this instance, the intelligence services. In the 'Last Word' section of the December 2001 issue of your Hi-Tech Security Solutions magazine your managing editor quotes almost exclusively from Jim Spencer's article, carried in the Security Technology & Design magazine published soon after the tragic events had occurred. This listed the failure of consultants, developers and manufacturers, integrators, customers, security associations, and insurance companies in providing the appropriate solutions to specific security needs.

The Managing Editors words are very apt. South African clients have been sold short by our own security professionals for many years. The main culprits being the so-called security consultants who pose as experts in the technical security field. They either do not follow the basic rules in order to produce a quality system design or much sadder they are not even aware of the fundamentals involved. There are five basic types of consultants encountered in South Africa:

* The ex-law enforcement or military types, usually good in the investigation and manpower field but lacking engineering experience; who at best recognise that they require assistance with the technical portion of the security plan and at worse attempt their own technical design with disastrous results for the client.

* The next is the consultant representing manpower or equipment firms who is a product salesman first and a consultant second with his first loyalty to the company that employs him. The end result is that the client finds he has paid for more security than he needs.

* The third type is the professional electrical engineer who provides the technical security requirements as part of his electrical brief. Over many years I have seen some very poorly compiled security enquiry documentation from this type of consultant. For example, still specifying tube cameras as part of their CCTV specification; calling for high resolution colour cameras which can obviously only be met by the monochrome type; issuing outdated specifications, or ones that have already been paid for by another client - in some instances they still contain references to the original client. However, the ultimate sin is calling for a high technical standard of equipment and then awarding the contract on a price basis for equipment which is nowhere near this requirement (that is, of a far lower specification) thus prejudicing the other tenderers who submitted prices strictly in accordance with the higher technical standards. I suspect that the consultants do not really understand what they specified in the first place.

* The fourth type is the in-house consultant. This person is normally appointed from within the company and although having the advantage of knowing the company business has no security experience. Not being prepared to inform his employer of his limitations this poor soul is easy prey for the second type of consultant (for consultant, read salesman) with all the negative ramifications.

* Lastly, there is the consultant who goes that extra mile to ensure that he understands the needs of his client so that he can design the appropriate security system to best meet these needs. Although having a general idea of the proper application of the various systems that may be used under specific conditions he also recognises that he cannot be an expert in all aspects of security manpower, procedures and hardware and thus calls on those that have the necessary skills and knowledge before compiling his security plan. One of the required fundamentals - compile a comprehensive security plan before attempting a technical design.

An important area in which the majority of consultants fall down is not preparing a detailed operational requirements document as part of their security plan (if indeed they use one). This can be considered a key document for security system designers as it states clearly what the client expects the system to be capable of doing. The development process encourages clear thinking about the what, where, when, by whom and in particular, the why in relation to the system. Without an operational requirement and matching test procedure there can be no guarantee that the system will be capable of performing its intended function. I have been involved with consultants who produce an access control design with equipment quantities and have no idea how visitors are to be processed - both at the perimeter entrance and the office reception point.

Security consultants can and do provide valuable services to their clients provided the client does a reasonably good job of selecting the right consultant in the first place. As a registered engineer who earns his living providing security technology consultancy services, I would caution prospective users of consulting services to use the same sound business judgment and standards in selecting a security consultant that they would in selecting any other type of consultant.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Highest increase in global cyberattacks in two years
Information Security News & Events
Check Point Global Research released new data on Q2 2024 cyber-attack trends, noting a 30% global increase in Q2 2024, with Africa experiencing the highest average weekly per organisation.

Read more...
From the Editor's desk: Apathy is a cybercriminal
Technews Publishing News & Events
      Welcome to SMART Security Solutions’ first print publication of the year, the SMART Access & Identity Handbook 2025. This year’s print issue is smaller than usual, so we include some articles in the ...

Read more...
From QR code to compromise
Information Security News & Events
A new attack vector involves threat actors using fraudulent QR codes emailed in PDF attachments to bypass companies' phishing security measures by requiring users to scan the code with their mobile phones.

Read more...
Boost revenue streams for MNOS
News & Events Security Services & Risk Management Financial (Industry)
ReveNet has introduced its new solution, designed to safeguard and potentially boost revenue streams in an increasingly challenging landscape for MNOS. The new platform combines advanced analytics and is built on trust, transparency, and sustainability principles.

Read more...
Here’s to a SMART 2025
SMART Security Solutions Editor's Choice News & Events
This is the final news brief from SMART Security Solutions for 2024, and the teams would like to take this opportunity to thank our readers, advertisers and partners and wish everyone a safe and secure festive season.

Read more...
Organisations fear AI-driven cyberattacks, but lack key defences
Kaspersky Information Security News & Events Training & Education
A recent Kaspersky study reveals that businesses are increasingly worried about the growing use of artificial intelligence in cyberattacks, with 56% of surveyed companies in South Africa reporting a rise in cyber incidents over the past year.

Read more...
South African SMBs chart growth amid economic uncertainties
News & Events
Survey shows that business confidence among South African SMBs remains strong at 78%, but opportunities abound to boost productivity and accelerate digital transformation. Additionally, AI adoption has gained traction, with two-thirds of South African SMBs investing in AI over the past year.

Read more...
ONVIF launches new online learning initiative
Training & Education Surveillance News & Events
ONVIF has released the first course in a new online learning initiative designed to promote greater knowledge and understanding of ONVIF's workings. The first “Introduction to ONVIF” course is now available.

Read more...
Gallagher Security opens Cape Town office
Gallagher News & Events Access Control & Identity Management
Acknowledging a significant period of growth for the company in South Africa, opening a second office will enable Gallagher to increase its presence across the region with staff based in Johannesburg and Cape Town.

Read more...
Physical security technology trends to watch in 2025
Technews Publishing News & Events
There are some exciting developments and significant changes, some technical and some operational, taking place in the market that security professionals should be aware of as they plan for the year ahead.

Read more...