The use of video to record police interviews takes off in the UK.

October 99 News & Events

The use of audio tape recorders for police interviews with suspects has now been commonly accepted by every UK police force. The Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) applies to the gathering and recording of interview evidence in criminal cases. Tape recorded interview evidence as permitted by PACE is firmly recognised as the most secure and reliable method of submitting interview evidence, unlike handwritten notes which can very often be disputed.

However, it has been questioned in court whether audio recordings allow room for interpretation and thus do not necessarily give the whole story. As a result some forces have experimented with the use of both audio and video taping of suspect interviews.

Det Supt John McGowan was one of the first interested in the benefit of this new technology: "We saw video recording of suspects and accused persons as a logical development from audio recording. No longer does the judge or jury rely on transcription or audio tape - the video recording encapsulates in realtime not only the physical and psychological state of the suspect or accused, but also the demeanour of both sides. Fairness is more easily demonstrated and falsehoods are more difficult to hide. The video has provided added confidence to officers who welcome the additional safeguards."

Key issues

A system using the audio and video technology should respond to a number of key issues. First of all, law enforcement in England, Wales and Scotland demands a minimum of two audio recording decks. Despite the fact that the video records sound, audio tapes are easier to work with, notably for the transcription and can be duplicated rapidly and in a cost-effective way.

Recorders designed and manufactured by NEAL Recording Systems have been approved by the Home Office since 1985. NEAL interview tape recorders are already in use in every police force in the UK and many abroad and can be upgraded with a separate NEAL video system. A compact audio and video system is also available.

It is essential that the time recorded by the audio and video tapes is exactly the same and can be clearly identified in terms of date and time. The video identification is possible with the burnt-in image which cannot be tampered with at a later time. In addition, the exact machine on which the recording has been made should also be shown - a clear identification number will ensure traceability here. Meanwhile, the audio recording normally uses the familiar speaking clock.

Another benefit is that this equipment has exactly the same controls as those already well known to all officers who have conducted an interview.

A series of safety alarms ensure that the recording is made successfully, as tape failure or bad microphone connection can often cause a fault.

Another matter that has caused much discussion is whether one broad view of the interview room should be complemented by a second camera providing a close-up of the suspect. In child witness recording suite situations, NEAL discovered that a picture-in-picture option could detail facial expression and therefore add reassurance.

The use of video for recording interviews provides further authentication devices to support police interview techniques and reinforces the validity of evidence gained in the interview room. Whilst audio provides the main evidential element of any recording, the significant additional contribution made by the video record can now help a judge or jury to understand the precise circumstances in which the interview was conducted.

For details contact Olivier Diesnis on telephone (0944) 191 418 1000, fax (0944) 191 418 1001 or e-mail:

Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Pentagon appointed as Milestone distributor
Elvey Security Technologies News & Events Surveillance
Milestone Systems appointed Pentagon Distribution (an Elvey Group company within the Hudaco Group of Companies) as a distributor. XProtect’s open architecture means no lock-in and the ability to customise the connected video solution that will accomplish the job.

Sophos celebrates partners and cybersecurity innovation at annual conference
News & Events Information Security
[Sponsored] Sun City hosted Sophos' annual partner event this year, which took place from 12 to 14 March. Sophos’ South African cybersecurity distributors and resellers gathered for an engaging two-day conference.

Sales basics for security installers
News & Events
Being the best security business in South Africa means little if no one uses your services. Your business success is only partly linked to how good you are at security installations.

From security technician to salesperson
News & Events
Being great at security sales starts with having the right mindset. How you think informs what you say and how you act; and how you act informs the results you will achieve in your business.

From the Editor's Desk: Something old and something new
Technews Publishing News & Events
      Welcome to the 2024 edition of SMART Security Solutions’ Mining Handbook. Mining is a challenging industry for security professionals, although security is a challenge on this continent, no matter your ...

Risk management: There's an app for that
Editor's Choice News & Events Risk Management & Resilience
Zulu Consulting has streamlined the corporate risk management process with the launch of Risk-IO, a web-based app designed to consolidate and guide risk managers through the process, monitoring progress as one proceeds.

Integrated information platform for risk management
Editor's Choice News & Events Risk Management & Resilience
Online Intelligence recently launched version 7 of its CiiMS risk and security platform. Speaking to SMART Security Solutions after the launch event, the company’s Arnold van den Bout described the enhancements in version 7.

Unlocking Africa's AI potential
Editor's Choice News & Events AI & Data Analytics
Africa's AI market is set to grow exponentially; by investing in AI education, training, and ethical practices, African nations can harness the power of AI to transform the continent and create a brighter future for its people.

Linking of security officers by security businesses
PSiRA (Private Security Ind. Regulatory Authority) News & Events Risk Management & Resilience
[Sponsored] By law, all security businesses are required to declare their employees to PSiRA so that they can be accounted for administratively. Failure to link employees by security businesses is a contravention of the Code of Conduct and a criminal offence.

Milestone XPerience Day South Africa
Milestone Systems News & Events
The 2024 Milestone XPerience Day in Johannesburg took place on 01 February 2024, where the video technology sector’s brightest and best minds gathered to share information and networking.