classic | mobile
Follow us on:
Follow us on Facebook  Share via Twitter  Share via LinkedIn

Hi-Tech Security Solutions Business Directory

Advantages of high-resolution IP cameras
May 2012, CCTV, Surveillance

Mobotix presents the case for use of high-resolution digital surveillance systems.

Even basic digital cameras provide more definition than the images from CCTV camera systems that are commonly used to identify terrorists. A simple comparison between digital and older technology clearly highlights the difference in image detail: the simplest of digital cameras stores images of around 3 million pixels (3 megapixels); in comparison, the classic video technology is restricted to 1/30 the pixels (101 000 pixels or 0,1 megapixels). Even the most inexperienced amateur photographer would not buy such a low-resolution camera these days. Despite these facts, this kind of security camera system is still being specified and deployed in a large number of public safety applications.

The poor quality of the images used in these public safety applications is not, as one would imagine, a result of the currently available technology, but rather the systems specified as the systems of choice. These, in turn, are based on television technology more than 50 years old, using video cameras that deliver live images with a maximum of 0,4 megapixels. Due to technical and cost constraints of these systems, the images are further reduced by a factor of 4:1 to just 0,1 megapixels, making facial recognition almost impossible.

Issues: 0,4 megapixels

So why do we not store the original image in 0,4 mega pixels? There are video systems that can store images at 0,4 megapixels, however, these are expensive and do not give the user sufficiently more detail. TV technology standard – the video stream is broadcast in half frames, and as the name suggests these have only half the detail. The electronic fitting together, or interlacing, of these half frames when viewing or recording moving objects, which is the most important aspect of security surveillance, causes combing distortion (blurred edges) in the image.

The image delivered by a video camera has 576 lines made up of two half frames, each with 288 lines, which are, exposed consecutively one after the other and then transmitted. Because of the technical and financial considerations mentioned earlier, most of the systems in use today are digitising and storing on a half frame basis. In context with the width to height ratio, 352 horizontal pixels are digitised for each of the 288 lines resulting in a so-called CIF image with 352 x 288 = 101 000 pixels, which is equivalent to 0,1 megapixels.

The 2CIF image format also uses only 288 lines but combines them with double the amount of pixels per line, giving us around 0,2 megapixels. Despite the increase in pixels per line, a considerable amount of important information is still missing from the image because every second line within each image is simply ignored, leaving us with what is accurately described as a half frame or half image.

Made up of two interlaced consecutive half images, a 4CIF format has indeed 704 x 576 = 0,4 megapixels but every second line is staggered or deferred because the half frames are exposed at different times. Because of this so-called combing effect, 4CIF recording is hardly ever used in actual systems. For example, at the World Cup stadiums only CIF, or in some cases 2CIF, half frames were recorded.

Snapshots unreliable in facial recognition

An additional problem with existing video technology lies in the low refresh rate of recorded images during playback. Again, because of technical and cost factors, 95% of existing systems cannot achieve more than 1-3 frames per second. With such a low refresh rate of snapshots, it becomes very difficult to find an image with enough detail for facial recognition.

This low playback rate is the result of one single computer having to digitise and store video feed from multiple cameras. The computing power for full video is generally only sufficient for two cameras; therefore, when recording more cameras the frame rate has to be drastically reduced.

Because of this limited processing power, MPEG4 also cannot be implemented for the recording of high-resolution video. The processing power is just not available for multiple cameras.

Why do the traditional surveillance camera manufacturers not simply use high-resolution sensors in their video cameras? The clear, but far from comforting answer is that the standard the systems are based on for the transmission and recording of images is 50 years old and it is technically impossible for the video cable to process such high-resolution images. Understandably, the video surveillance industry is reluctant to change; however, to protect the public, change is inevitable.

The digital difference: IP cameras

New digital technologies also present opportunities for innovative manufacturers to offer new solutions. In the last few years, there has been an emphasis on developing megapixel technology and transmitting video streams via modern computer networks, LAN, WAN, WLAN or over the Internet. In order to achieve this, a high-performance processor with extensive software package for processing, compressing, recording and storage of the image sequences was developed and integrated into the video camera itself.

One of the great advantages of modern network camera technology is the ability to manage all configurations and to access live and stored images simultaneously while the camera is recording, remotely over the network, anytime, from anywhere in the world. These camera installations will be linked on the existing company network or even the Internet via a secured connection (VPN) and firewall.

In this way, any incident or suspicious behaviour in a train station, airport or any other public place can be immediately investigated by retrieving the images to the control centre via the network without the necessity of having someone on site or having to stop the recording and live viewing. New or improved software for further functionality can simply be loaded into the camera through the network.

The use of worldwide IT standards makes it possible to integrate inexpensive system components: whether over copper, glass or wireless via WLAN. A power outlet is not necessary as cameras do not require heating to prevent misting and as a result can be supplied with power via the network cable all year round.

A direct comparison

A comparison of a CIF image with 288 lines and a camera image with 960 lines dramatically highlights the difference in quality and detail. Megapixel imaging shows 12 times more detailed resolution, so that a face taking up only 1/40th of the image width is still clearly recognisable. With the appropriate post editing, the image quality can be further improved. In comparison, the image extracted from the CIF image is unrecognisable and therefore unusable.

Many IP cameras or network cameras are still using the old analogue technology internally and merely transmit a digitised image via a computer network. Although it is hard to believe, most IP camera systems are only storing CIF half frames!

Switching from MPEG4 TO MXPEG

The video standard MPEG4 was developed for compressing a single video stream (e.g. movie) and not for the compression, management and viewing of multiple high-resolution cameras. MPEG4 transmits moving objects at lower resolution and quality because the human eye does not take in all the detail of a moving object; therefore, it makes no difference when watching a movie. For this very reason, MPEG4 is not suitable for security systems because in a security situation, it is these moving objects that are of great importance and must be therefore highly detailed.

To handle the needs of security video, the video standard MxPEG, requiring around only 2 Mbps for a high-resolution video stream and exhibiting a shorter reaction time than MPEG4 is ideal. The MxPEG standard is currently being implemented and supported by manufacturers and developers worldwide.

For more information contact IAC, +27 (0)12 657 3600, ,

Supplied By: Industrial Automation & Control (IAC)
Tel: +27 12 657 3600
Fax: +27 12 657 3630
  Share via Twitter   Share via LinkedIn      

Further reading:

  • IP video door stations
    November 2015, Axis Communications SA, Access Control & Identity Management, CCTV, Surveillance
    Enhancing video surveillance with communication and entry control. Pace and progress may differ, but industry after industry is adopting IP technology.
  • Making video surveillance easy
    November 2015, Bosch Security Systems, CCTV, Surveillance
    The new FLEXIDOME IP 4000 and FLEXIDOME IP 5000 cameras from Bosch make professional video surveillance easy for everyone.
  • Museum secures its history
    November 2015, Bosch Security Systems, Access Control & Identity Management, CCTV, Surveillance, Fire & Safety, Case Studies, System Integration
    Preserving a thousand years of life, Museum of the History of Polish Jews secured by Bosch.
  • Access module eases admittance
    November 2015, Milestone Systems, Asset Management, EAS, RFID, CCTV, Surveillance, Access Control & Identity Management, Case Studies
    Milestone access control solution with Axis products secures commercial premises controlled by Milestone XProtect Professional.
  • Surveillance vs. administration
    November 2015, Leaderware, CCTV, Surveillance
    Are we killing natural or open surveillance and the benefits that came out of really good operators picking up things?
  • Stopping theft in its tracks
    November 2015, Sukema Integrated Solutions, Ingram Micro South Africa, This Week's Editor's Pick, CCTV, Surveillance, Asset Management, EAS, RFID, Remote Monitoring
    While theft of cargo continues to be a major issue for the transportation industry, another expensive trend is gaining impetus: theft of diesel as well as truck and trailer tyres.
  • Video analytics: the road ahead
    November 2015, Axis Communications SA, Cathexis Technologies, This Week's Editor's Pick, CCTV, Surveillance
    Video analytics has come a long way to where it is a reliable and trusted addition to video surveillance today. Hi-Tech Security Solutions looks at the state of video analytics and where it’s going.
  • Axis offers video analytics
    November 2015, Axis Communications SA, News, CCTV, Surveillance
    Axis introduces video analytics with the easy to install Axis Guard Suite for enhanced video surveillance efficiency.
  • Short-term investment for long-term benefit
    November 2015, Elvey Security Technologies, CCTV, Surveillance, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, System Integration
    Jack Edery, CEO of Elvey, says that not prioritising security is an unwise and short-sighted move which leaves both homeowners and businesses vulnerable.
  • In-vehicle surveillance solution
    November 2015, Transport (Industry), CCTV, Surveillance, Asset Management, EAS, RFID
    GeoVision SA has announced a tracking and surveillance solution for fleet owners in South Africa. The solution offers users the ability to track a vehicle via GPS as well as view live video footage from cameras installed in the vehicles.
  • Dash cam with driver alerts
    November 2015, Garmin Southern Africa, Transport (Industry), CCTV, Surveillance
    Garmin Southern Africa has announced the new Dash Cam 30 and Dash Cam 35, high-definition standalone driving recorders which easily mount to a windshield and record footage in a continuous loop.
  • Shopping for peace of mind
    November 2015, Axis Communications SA, CCTV, Surveillance, Case Studies, Retail (Industry)
    Axis network cameras deployed to secure the interior and exterior of Cape Town shopping mall.

Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory (HSBD)

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual
    Mobile | Classic

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.