Protecting historic buildings from fire risk

Issue 6 2021 Fire & Safety

The issue of protecting heritage structures and other buildings containing priceless artefacts or documents from fire risk came into stark focus in mid-April. A blaze originating at Table Mountain eventually swept onto the upper campus of the University of Cape Town (UCT). It caused extensive damage to the African Studies Library reading room, known previously as the JW Jagger Library. Built in the 1930s, it is home to many international research collections, with an estimated 85 000 items in total.

The first factor to consider is that the reading room was obviously not designed initially for that purpose. “It is particularly challenging where you have a building that did not necessarily have fire resistance measures incorporated into its design,” points out ASP Fire CEO, Michael van Niekerk. Has the building been adapted from its original function and construction, or is it a relatively new building that can accommodate such measures?

In terms of an historic building where the walls, floors and doors cannot be rendered fireproof, an alternative passive fire-safety approach is to adopt a fire-rated shelving system. Such mobile shelves can then simply be wheeled out of harm’s way for safe transfer of the contents outside. However, caution must be taken in not opening any external doors that can introduce more oxygen into the burning building, causing the fire to get out of control.

Avoiding suppression damage

Another option is to use a gas fire suppression system designed specifically for archives and libraries, which have the benefit of not leaving behind any damaging residue. The challenge here is that because libraries present such large spaces, the quantity of gas required is quite considerable. Hence the larger question is the protection of the heritage building itself versus its contents. While older buildings may have a stone or brick superstructure, the flooring and internal structure is generally made from timber.

The construction materials used in older buildings are definitely not in line with modern regulations. Complicating the issue is that heritage buildings are very difficult to retrofit with conventional sprinkler systems, for example, due to the fact that their external appearance has to be preserved. However, there is a responsibility on any building owner to ensure that a building is fit-for-purpose in terms of fire protection, which extends to both loss of valuable property and loss of life.

“The risk is that we possibly lose a building, as opposed to trying to save the contents. However, that is a strategy that the building owners or the trust in charge of a particular heritage building needs to consider,” comments Van Niekerk. The fact that the fire that devastated the African Studies Library reading room originated outside indicates that attention needs to be paid to wildland urban fire interfaces that can protect such buildings, for example.

Modern buildings also deploy drencher systems that keep the exterior cool with water curtains in order to protect windows, doors, walls and roofs against an encroaching fire. “This is probably the best strategy to adopt in the event of a fire like the recent Table Mountain blaze, as it means a heat shield is essentially created around a building in order to protect it,” says Van Niekerk.

A proper fire-risk assessment

In addition to modern advances like recessed sprinkler systems, which are only activated in the event of a fire, another solution is a hypoxic system that introduces nitrogen into an area to reduce the oxygen level to the point where spontaneous combustion cannot occur.

However, the best approach remains a proper fire-risk assessment, which looks at a building holistically and not in isolation to any other factors. What is the environment that surrounds the building? This played a critical role in the Cape Town fire, which propagated in the fynbos of Table Mountain and quickly spread. “In this instance there was a driven wildland fire with burning brands being blown towards buildings,” notes Van Niekerk.

There are also internal factors that need to be considered, such as the possible sources of ignition inside a building and how best to manage these. Notwithstanding that a building is old, the electrical system can still be modernised without affecting its heritage ‘look and feel’. In addition, modern electrical management systems based on earth leakage and thermal resistors, as well as computer monitoring, can result in an automatic shutdown if any risks are detected. These can range from fans, heaters and computer terminals that are left on to overloaded multi-plug extensions, a common cause of fire in a typical office environment.

Introduce refuge areas

“Managing the internal environment of a building adequately allows for the fire risk to be minimised. Obviously, risk can never be eliminated by 100%, but it can definitely be reduced to an acceptable level,” notes Van Niekerk. An effective means to achieve this is to introduce refuge areas into heritage buildings in particular, which forms part of the overall life-safety strategy. A refuge area has its own oxygen supply and fire-rated walls and doors in order to protect occupants until a fire dies down or is brought under control.

“There is an onus on the owners or trustees of a heritage or historic building to safeguard that building against fire. This is a risk assessment that any responsible building owner should conduct.”




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Hotel enhances guest safety and aesthetics
Fire & Safety
Hotel Montresor Tower, a stylish four-star destination just outside Verona, Italy, has successfully upgraded its fire detection infrastructure with Hochiki's advanced Latitude life safety platform.

Read more...
Directory of suppliers
Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Fire & Safety
The Directory of Product and Solution Suppliers for the fire safety industry includes details of companies that provide security and risk mitigation products, advice, and services within this market.

Read more...
Detect fires in the early stages
Securiton Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
The SecuriSmoke range from Securiton offers various levels of coverage and power to suit every budget and application. What all the models have in common is that they can detect smoke in very small quantities.

Read more...
SecuriHeat ADW linear heat detector
Securiton Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
The SecuriHeat ADW linear heat detector uses sealed tubes positioned over the detection area, and a remotely positioned control unit detects pressure changes in the tubes brought about by changing temperature.

Read more...
Fire safety in commercial kitchens
Technews Publishing Kestrel Distribution Products & Solutions Fire & Safety Commercial (Industry)
Fire safety in commercial kitchens is becoming increasingly critical. Defender is Europe’s first EN 17446:2021-approved kitchen hood fire suppression system and offers the indispensable safety measures required.

Read more...
The crucial role of fire, smoke, and gas detectors
Fire & Safety Facilities & Building Management
From wireless detectors to integrated building management systems, the industry is seeing a significant shift towards more intelligent, more responsive solutions. ASP Fire CEO Michael van Niekerk shares insights into these innovations.

Read more...
South African fire standards in a nutshell
Fire & Safety Editor's Choice Training & Education
The importance of compliant fire detection systems and proper fire protection cannot be overstated, especially for businesses. Statistics reveal that 44% of businesses fail to reopen after a fire.

Read more...
Secutel maintains ISO certifications
News & Events Fire & Safety
Secutel Technologies has successfully recertified all four of its ISO standards, a reflection of its continued commitment to excellence, client trust, and operational integrity.

Read more...
Protecting solar panel installations
Technoswitch Fire Detection & Suppression Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
Vulcan Integrated Solutions partnered with Technoswitch and installed Protectowire’s Confirmed Temperature Initiation (CTI) Series Linear Heat Detection (LHD) system, specifically designed for harsh environments, to offer fire protection for solar panels.

Read more...
LidarVision for substation security
Fire & Safety Government and Parastatal (Industry) Editor's Choice
EG.D supplies electricity to 2,7 million people in the southern regions of the Czech Republic, on the borders of Austria and Germany. The company operates and maintains infrastructure, including power lines and high-voltage transformer substations.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.