Hybrid: best of both worlds?

CCTV Handbook 2013 Surveillance

Hybrid solutions are touted as the ideal middle ground solution for users who either cannot or do not wish to replace their entire analogue system with IP. Common questions that come to the fore are whether they really do offer the best of both technology worlds, or do they simply offer median performance levels?

Gus Brecher, MD at Cathexis Africa says it is important to define a hybrid solution. “Only if both analogue and IP cameras on a site are being monitored from a common control room or management platform can one truly say that it is a hybrid solution. Currently, there are traditional DVRs which have the ability to accommodate IP cameras, and then there is the option to insert IP encoders to convert the analogue video stream to IP.

“There are some solutions that transmit HD video along co-axial cables, but I believe that this is not a long-term solution as it normally requires proprietary hardware which is not compatible with all open systems. This may present problems with future upgradeability of systems. Seamless, simultaneous operation of both analogue and IP video streams should be the goal of any installation.”

“Hybrid systems are essentially analogue and IP solutions. It is important that one be able to use them together on a platform to ensure maximised operability,” says Ingo Mutinelli, national sales manager for Elvey Security Technologies.

Gordon Moore, ADI product manager CCTV/Access, adds that there are three ways of achieving a hybrid solution:

* Hybrid DVRs: these are purpose-built recorders that will have a combination of composite video inputs for the analogue cameras and an Ethernet port for the IP cameras. These solutions are common in smaller installations ranging from 16 to 32 inputs.

* CMSs: central management software designed to be able to connect to both DVRs and NVRs. This, in most cases, would be software developed by the manufacturer to allow end-users to view cameras from their older DVR and their newer NVRs, on one common platform.

* Encoders: this is probably the most common solution in larger ­projects where there have already been large investments with analogue cameras in the infrastructure. In this case, one would make use of IP encoders to convert the analogue images to IP so that they can be incorporated into a full IP solution.

Let’s go

“One needs to consider the implementation costs versus the future relevance of the solution when considering a hybrid solution. A middle road is to offer an upgrade with some IP technology, but simultaneously retain existing analogue cameras. Ultimately, it is necessary to perform a needs analysis to guarantee not only the ability to upgrade a system, but also to determine whether the system can be supported and integrated 10 years down the line,” notes Brecher.

“There are two basic considerations when converting to hybrid solutions. Firstly, what are the storage requirements? Secondly, which analogue cameras would you need to convert into IP and how will this signal scale from point A to point B,” says Mutinelli. “One should also consider the limitations such as what kind of infrastructure is available in terms of the network capacity. This will be affected by what resolution is required and how many frames per second are recorded.”

Is hybrid the solution?

In the beginning, when the industry started with IP, there was a requirement for hybrid solutions because IP had not matured. There were many instances where analogue was required for specific areas or functionality, such as high-speed domes, thermal cameras and areas where large zoom lenses were required. This has changed. IP image quality has now improved significantly and there is an IP solution for every possible scenario. “So, the only consideration for a hybrid solution now would be instances where there has been significant investment in analogue and there are budgetary constraints that restrict one from instituting a full upgrade,” says Moore.

When implementing a hybrid solution one needs to understand that you will not get the same image quality as a full IP solution. If the image quality of the analogue camera has deteriorated, converting it to IP with an encoder will make the image worse because of the way the compression engine works. A noisy image is always difficult to compress, he adds.

“If you are happy with your analogue camera-to-video quality, then it would be foolish to change to IP. However, if you need higher image resolution, then you need to consider IP. With hybrid, you can simultaneously embrace the latest technology, while retaining your existing investment. It is critical, however, to have a centralised management system,” says Brecher.

As the technology improves, IP becomes more affordable. However, until bandwidth issues have been resolved, it is often a good idea to stick with analogue systems. IP is ideal where the user is operating in a remote or very large location, according to Mutinelli.

“Hybrid solutions allow for cost-effective upgrade paths, where one can migrate across to IP over a period without having to start from scratch. Therefore, if cost is an issue then hybrid solutions do provide the best of both worlds but, at the end of the day, nothing beats a full IP solution,” Moore concludes.



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

From the editor's desk: We’ve only just begun
Technews Publishing News & Events
The surveillance market has expanded far beyond the analogue days of just recording and/or monitoring screens. The capabilities of surveillance technology today extend to black screen monitoring with ...

Read more...
The future of the surveillance channel
Duxbury Networking Technews Publishing Elvey Security Technologies SMART Security Solutions Surveillance
The video surveillance market has evolved from camera-based specifications to integrated solutions that solve customers’ problems. Moreover, the growth of AI and cloud has changed the channel even more, with more to come.

Read more...
The benefits of offsite control rooms
Astrosec Surveillance Integrated Solutions
As the security landscape grows more intricate, control rooms – the crucial hub of security operations – need to adapt. With escalating costs, mounting threats, and a heightened demand for immediate responses, many organisations are reassessing the operations of their control rooms.

Read more...
CCTV control room operator job description
Leaderware Editor's Choice Surveillance Training & Education
Control room operators are still critical components of security operations and will remain so for the foreseeable future, despite the advances of AI, which serves as a vital enhancement to the human operator.

Read more...
Hikvision launches latest range of cameras
Hikvision South Africa Surveillance AI & Data Analytics
Hikvision has launched its latest network cameras with ColorVu 3.0 technology and EasyIP 4.0 Plus, which elevate video security by delivering improved image quality, enhanced intelligent functions, superior audio capabilities, and a refined product design and materials.

Read more...
Platform to access data and train AI models
Milestone Systems AI & Data Analytics Surveillance
Milestone Systems has announced Project Hafnia to build services and democratise AI-model training with high-quality, compliant video data leveraging NVIDIA Cosmos Curator and AI model, fine-tuning microservices.

Read more...
The capabilities of visual verification
Secutel Technologies Surveillance AI & Data Analytics
Secutel Technologies has provided locally developed visual verification solutions for some time. SMART Security Solutions requested more insight into these solutions from the company.

Read more...
AI means proactive surveillance
DeepAlert Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions AI & Data Analytics Surveillance
SMART Security Solutionsasked DeepAlert for some insight into how AI is transforming video surveillance, even to the extent of it being taught to protect the privacy of those in the cameras’ view.

Read more...
Integration is the key to smarter surveillance
Duxbury Networking Surveillance
According to recent market projections, the local security industry is expected to grow by more than 10% annually through 2029, reflecting the increasing demand for smarter, more proactive security solutions.

Read more...
edgE:Tower video analytics integrated with SEON
Surveillance Integrated Solutions AI & Data Analytics
Sentronics has announced a new integration between its edgE:Tower advanced AI-driven video analytics solution and SEON, a Central Monitoring Software (CMS) platform. This integration enhances real-time situational awareness and automated threat detection for control rooms.

Read more...