Katrina and security

March 2006 Integrated Solutions

Leaving aside the political posturing and the finger-pointing, how did the US nation mis-handle Katrina so badly? After spending tens of billions of dollars on homeland security (hundreds of billions, if you include the war in Iraq) in the four years after 9/11, what did they do wrong? Why were there so many failures at the local, state and federal levels?

These are reasonable questions. Katrina was a natural disaster and not a terrorist attack, but that only matters before the event. Large-scale terrorist attacks and natural disasters differ in cause, but they are very similar in aftermath. And one can easily imagine a Katrina-like aftermath to a terrorist attack, especially one involving nuclear, biological or chemical weapons.

Improving our disaster response was discussed in the months after 9/11. We were going to give money to local governments to fund first responders. We established the Department of Homeland Security to streamline the chains of command and facilitate efficient and effective response.

The problem is that we all got caught up in 'movie-plot threats', specific attack scenarios that capture the imagination and then the dollars. Whether it is terrorists with box cutters or bombs in their shoes, we fear what we can imagine. We are searching backpacks in the subways of New York, because this year's movie plot is based on a terrorist bombing in the London subways.

Funding security based on movie plots looks good on television, and gets people re-elected. But there are millions of possible scenarios, and we are going to guess wrong. The billions spent defending airlines are wasted if the terrorists bomb crowded shopping malls instead.

The US needs to spend its homeland security dollars on two things: intelligence-gathering and emergency response. These two things will help us regardless of what the terrorists are plotting, and the second helps both against terrorist attacks and national disasters.

Katrina demonstrated that we have not invested enough in emergency response. New Orleans police officers could not talk with each other after power outages shut down their primary communications system - and there was no backup. The Department of Homeland Security, which was established in order to centralise federal response in a situation like this, could not figure out who was in charge or what to do, and actively obstructed aid by others. FEMA did no better, and thousands died while turf battles were being fought.

The US government's ineptitude in the aftermath of Katrina demonstrates how little we are getting for all our security spending. It is unconscionable that we are wasting our money fingerprinting foreigners, profiling airline passengers, and invading foreign countries while emergency response at home goes underfunded.

Money spent on emergency response makes us safer, regardless of what the next disaster is, whether terrorist-made or natural.

This includes good communications on the ground, good coordination up the command chain, and resources - people and supplies - that can be quickly deployed wherever they are needed.

Similarly, money spent on intelligence-gathering makes us safer, regardless of what the next disaster is. Against terrorism, that includes the NSA and the CIA. Against natural disasters, that includes the National Weather Service and the National Earthquake Information Center.

Katrina deftly illustrated homeland security's biggest challenge: guessing correctly. The solution is to fund security that does not rely on guessing. Defending against movie plots does not make us appreciably safer. Emergency response does. It lessens the damage and suffering caused by disasters, whether man-made, like 9/11, or nature-made, like Katrina.

Bruce Schneier is the founder and CTO of Counterpane Internet Security, Inc. He can be contacted at [email protected]. To subscribe to a free monthly newsletter providing summaries, analyses, insights and commentaries on security: computer and otherwise, visit http://www.schneier.com/crypto-gram.html





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Cost-effective and reliable remote connectivity
Agriculture (Industry) Integrated Solutions Infrastructure
Companies that operate in hard-to-connect areas now have access to reliable connectivity due to a collaboration between MTN South Africa, Vox and Tarana technology.

Read more...
Advanced Perimeter Intrusion Detection Systems
XtraVision OPTEX Technews Publishing Modular Communications Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection Integrated Solutions Products & Solutions
Making full use of fibre installations around the perimeter by adding Perimeter Intrusion Detection Systems means you can easily add another layer of security to existing surveillance and fencing systems.

Read more...
A critical component of perimeter security
Nemtek Electric Fencing Products Gallagher Technews Publishing Stafix Editor's Choice Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection Integrated Solutions
Electric fences are standard in South Africa, but today, they also need to be able to integrate with other technologies and become part of a broader perimeter security solution.

Read more...
Using advanced surveillance technology as a smart city enabler
Duxbury Networking Integrated Solutions Surveillance
Smart cities are increasingly becoming a focus area for African governments and companies. However, the transition to these environments does not come without challenges, especially when it comes to security and resource management.

Read more...
SMART Estate Security returns to KZN
Nemtek Electric Fencing Products Technews Publishing Axis Communications SA OneSpace Technologies Editor's Choice News & Events Integrated Solutions IoT & Automation
The second SMART Estate Security Conference of 2024 was held in May in KwaZulu-Natal at the Mount Edgecombe Estate Conference Centre, which is located on the Estate’s pristine golf course.

Read more...
Dynamic Dashboard enhances security and operational efficiency
Suprema neaMetrics Products & Solutions Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry)
In today’s data-driven world, security systems are overwhelmed by an unprecedented volume of data, from video surveillance and access control logs to intrusion alerts and a variety of IoT sensor data.

Read more...
HELLO visitor access management
Products & Solutions Access Control & Identity Management Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry)
HELLO is an on-premises visitor and contractor access management solution designed to be fully integrated and complementary with smart, on-trend technologies, securing estates and businesses alike.

Read more...
Using KPIs to measure smart city progress
Axis Communications SA Residential Estate (Industry) Integrated Solutions Security Services & Risk Management
United 4 Smart Sustainable Cities is a United Nations Initiative that encourages the use of information and communication technology (including security technology) to support a smooth transition to smart cities.

Read more...
Enhancing estate security, the five-layer approach
Fang Fences & Guards Residential Estate (Industry) Integrated Solutions Security Services & Risk Management
Residential estates are designed to provide a serene and secure living environment enclosed within gated communities, offering residents peace of mind and an elevated standard of living.

Read more...
Creating employment through entrepreneurship
Technews Publishing Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry)
Eduardo Takacs’s journey is a testament to bona fide entrepreneurial resilience, making him stand out in a country desperate for resilient businesses in the small and medium enterprise space that can create employment opportunities.

Read more...