International trends in standardising aspirating smoke detectors (ASD)

November 2008 Fire & Safety

As a signatory country to the worldwide ISO standards, the South African fire detection industry should take interest in the publication and adoption of EN54-20 'Fire detection and fire alarm systems – Part 20: aspirating smoke detectors' by European signatory countries.

As local awareness of aspirating technology improves, this standard will go a long way to ensure the distinction between reputable products and those that are either unapproved or inappropriate for the intended applications.

Reference to www.EN54-20.org outlines the important points to consider when establishing the implications such a standard would have on the local fire detection industry.

For instance, a classification system has been introduced enabling identification of the most appropriate sensitivity of an aspirating smoke detector for an application:

This sensitivity classification system employs test fires of differing smoke dilution and fuel to fire test the product. Essentially, Class C test fires are used to demonstrate normal sensitivities, ie, sensitivities similar to optical point type smoke detectors. For Class A and Class B testing, fires with reduced fuel content and increased smoke dilution are employed to establish high or enhanced sensitivity.

Integrity of airflow through the sampling pipe network is also specifically addressed with a requirement of ±20% change to indicate airflow fault. Although this may create some engineering challenges for some manufacturers, it would ultimately lend itself to greater reliability.

The standard also addresses the pass criteria for the smoke tests by way of a defined 'End of Test' or EoT. This addresses the inherent transport time delay an aspirating system has.

Sure, the detector may detect smoke, but if a system only responds after a conventional type detector and after the test fire has finished, it provides little benefit and makes a mockery of any minimum standard and aspirating technology as a whole. EN54-20 addresses this and it is incorporated into the classification system.

What should be considered here is that the classification system is not a system identifying products of differing qualities, it does not extend so far as to recognise product features such as alarm thresholds, ease of use, maintenance, etc. As www.EN54-20.org points out, the system makes no differentiation between, say, a detector with 30 holes (Class A) versus a detector with only 3 Class A holes – “The stark difference in area coverage is also reflected in the detector’s ability to provide the earliest possible warning of smoke…” so the risk would be that, without disclosure of the number of holes supported, a detector with fairly low sensitivity could be marketed as performing at a higher sensitivity classification than it realistically can.

The classification is rather a reference to detector sensitivity and assists with decision making in terms of applicable technology. The standard would not be used to compare one product to another. What it would go a long way to achieving, particularly in RSA, is empowering professionals to identify sensitivity and capability of a system they choose to use.

What is ASD?

An aspirating smoke detector is a smoke detector which provides protection by drawing air into a detector unit. This is done via a network of sampling pipes and capillaries where sampled air is passed through the system and analysed for the presence of combustion products.

Aspirating systems usually draw sampled air from multiple holes spaced around a protected area – the cumulative effect of smoke entering more than one hole results in the system being more responsive than smoke entering only one sampling point.

The detection element inside these devices is often based on laser technology using the optical scatter principle. Other methods include cloud chambers and even embedded optical point type smoke detectors.

Aspirating detectors are traditionally used for applications where early warning of fire is paramount and protection of assets is key. These include business-critical computer servers or telecoms installations where business continuity cannot be jeopardised. Other applications include where building aesthetics are a priority or challenging environments for maintenance or where high airflows are present.

For more information contact Patrick Denyssen, Xtralis, +27 (0)82 906 0219, [email protected], www.xtralis.com, www.vesda.com





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Hotel enhances guest safety and aesthetics
Fire & Safety
Hotel Montresor Tower, a stylish four-star destination just outside Verona, Italy, has successfully upgraded its fire detection infrastructure with Hochiki's advanced Latitude life safety platform.

Read more...
Directory of suppliers
Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Fire & Safety
The Directory of Product and Solution Suppliers for the fire safety industry includes details of companies that provide security and risk mitigation products, advice, and services within this market.

Read more...
Detect fires in the early stages
Securiton Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
The SecuriSmoke range from Securiton offers various levels of coverage and power to suit every budget and application. What all the models have in common is that they can detect smoke in very small quantities.

Read more...
SecuriHeat ADW linear heat detector
Securiton Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
The SecuriHeat ADW linear heat detector uses sealed tubes positioned over the detection area, and a remotely positioned control unit detects pressure changes in the tubes brought about by changing temperature.

Read more...
Fire safety in commercial kitchens
Technews Publishing Kestrel Distribution Products & Solutions Fire & Safety Commercial (Industry)
Fire safety in commercial kitchens is becoming increasingly critical. Defender is Europe’s first EN 17446:2021-approved kitchen hood fire suppression system and offers the indispensable safety measures required.

Read more...
The crucial role of fire, smoke, and gas detectors
Fire & Safety Facilities & Building Management
From wireless detectors to integrated building management systems, the industry is seeing a significant shift towards more intelligent, more responsive solutions. ASP Fire CEO Michael van Niekerk shares insights into these innovations.

Read more...
South African fire standards in a nutshell
Fire & Safety Editor's Choice Training & Education
The importance of compliant fire detection systems and proper fire protection cannot be overstated, especially for businesses. Statistics reveal that 44% of businesses fail to reopen after a fire.

Read more...
Secutel maintains ISO certifications
News & Events Fire & Safety
Secutel Technologies has successfully recertified all four of its ISO standards, a reflection of its continued commitment to excellence, client trust, and operational integrity.

Read more...
Protecting solar panel installations
Technoswitch Fire Detection & Suppression Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
Vulcan Integrated Solutions partnered with Technoswitch and installed Protectowire’s Confirmed Temperature Initiation (CTI) Series Linear Heat Detection (LHD) system, specifically designed for harsh environments, to offer fire protection for solar panels.

Read more...
LidarVision for substation security
Fire & Safety Government and Parastatal (Industry) Editor's Choice
EG.D supplies electricity to 2,7 million people in the southern regions of the Czech Republic, on the borders of Austria and Germany. The company operates and maintains infrastructure, including power lines and high-voltage transformer substations.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.