Security gap scenario

October 2005 Integrated Solutions

Mr CFO is travelling abroad, therefore has not checked into his office via his access control card at the main turnstile in the New York City office. He has, however, checked into his office in Paris, France and will be working there for the next 10 days. The physical access control system in New York is a different system, completely independent from the one securing the office in France. Therefore, the guards monitoring the system in New York City are not even aware that Mr CFO is not in the building.

In the meantime, a trusted employee has been looking over Mr CFO's shoulder and has acquired his login credentials, which are simply username and password. Knowing he is out of the country for 10 days, and on a very different time schedule, she logs onto the network, during normal working hours, and accesses sensitive files, which she will later share with competitors.

Will an alarm be annunciated anywhere? No. Why?

There is no apparent violation in either the physical access system, nor the network access system, which are operating independently.

* The employee committing the crime is authorised to enter the building during US, EST working hours, so nothing will be annunciated in the physical access system, or even flagged as abnormal.

* The network security system sees Mr CFO logging on and accessing files that he is authorised to view during time periods that are otherwise normal for him. Therefore, nothing will be annunciated or flagged as a network security breach. Effective security management combining both physical and IT controls could result in organisationally and operationally coordinated security.

* If the physical access systems were compatible, the guards monitoring the facilities may have at least known that Mr CFO was entering the facility in France, not locally in New York.

* If the physical access system was communicating activity to the network access system, Mr CFO's credentials may authorise him local access, only where he appears to be physically located.

* If the physical access system was communicating to the network access system, it would annunciate an alarm if Mr CFO logged onto the network remotely or in another location than he appears to physically be located based on the last doors he physically accessed.

* If the physical security department had procedures in place to communicate abnormal events such as this, they would notify the network security department of a possible security breech.

* If the credentials required for Mr CFO to enter the facility in France were also required for him to log onto the corporate network, another person would not be able to utilise his credentials.

By Laurie Aaron, Tyco Safety Products, courtesy of Faulkner Information Services.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

A layered approach to safety in schools
Surveillance Integrated Solutions Education (Industry)
Physical security in schools and learning institutions is a hot topic in South Africa, with the Gauteng Department of Education recently announcing plans to use AI-powered cameras and biometric access to strengthen school safety.

Read more...
Integrated layers offer dependable security
OPTEX SMART Security Solutions Technews Publishing Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection Integrated Solutions
A layered approach to security tightens protection and minimises downtime and operational risk. Moreover, integrating all the parts of a solution and proving they can do the job before spending money are critical.

Read more...
Digital ID and facial recognition for safer learning institutions
Integrated Solutions Education (Industry)
As crime rises, South African schools and tertiary education institutions are locked in an ongoing battle to secure their premises and keep children and students safe. Focusing on advanced digital safeguards could provide enhanced situational awareness and more effective yet unobtrusive protection.

Read more...
Strengthening critical infrastructure security
Integrated Solutions
Security is a top priority for any organisation responsible for safeguarding critical infrastructure. However, recent events have highlighted the fragility of the global energy supply chain and the need for change.

Read more...
Impro announces Primo update
News & Events Access Control & Identity Management Integrated Solutions
Impro Technologies recently held a launch event in which it introduced a series of new products, from new readers through to its updated Primo access management software.

Read more...
The security debt hidden in residential estates
Security Services & Risk Management Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry)
Many residential estates undermine their own security not through a lack of technology, but through hidden weaknesses in gate design, fragmented systems, recurring software dependence, weak operational ownership, and insufficient estate management input.

Read more...
Proactive estate security in Cape Town
neaMetrics OneSpace Technologies Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Fang Fences & Guards ATG Digital Editor's Choice News & Events Integrated Solutions Infrastructure Residential Estate (Industry)
SMART Security Solutions started the year with our annual SMART Estate Security Conference in Cape Town on 26 February 2026. Held at Anna Beulah Farm, the conference saw a number of delegates enjoying the farm’s excellent cuisine, while listening to outstanding presenters.

Read more...
Data privacy best practices for physical security teams
Genetec Surveillance Integrated Solutions IoT & Automation
Physical security systems produce large amounts of information from video footage, access control records, and licence plate data. Recommendations assist organisations in safeguarding sensitive data, while ensuring effective security operations.

Read more...
Gallagher Security strengthens KwaZulu-Natal presence
Gallagher News & Events Integrated Solutions
Gallagher Security has reinforced its commitment to the KwaZulu-Natal region with its Command the Future event. The full-day event welcomed over 100 channel partners, end users, and consultants, marking Gallagher’s third major event in Durban.

Read more...
Surveillance & AI roundtable
DeepAlert Lytehouse Refraime SMART Security Solutions Technews Publishing Editor's Choice Surveillance Integrated Solutions AI & Data Analytics
SMART Security Solutions held an online roundtable with a few surveillance experts to explore the intersection of surveillance and AI, gaining insights into the market and how control rooms are evolving.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.