Counterfeit reality: Gartner says new laws must be passed to combat rise of counterfeit reality

December 2004 News

While digital media presents companies with new options for handling information, it also allows unscrupulous entities to create an entire world of digital forgeries that will become virtually impossible to detect through casual inspection. Digital media has created new possibilities in counterfeit reality, with many images no longer easily certified as real. This rise of counterfeit reality increasingly will lead to disputes over interpretations of social, political, legal and business realities that the judicial system and other institutions of conflict resolution are not equipped to resolve, according to Gartner.

Gartner defines counterfeit reality as the digital creation of images, video, documents or sounds that are convincingly realistic representations of things that never occurred or never existed exactly as represented.

In the past, it was reasonable to assume that a photograph was good enough evidence to 'establish a reality' in a court. Today, photographs are scrutinised by experts in court, but few people know how to spot an enhanced, forged or fake image.

"Laws covering admissibility of electronic documents in courts will need to be revamped to anticipate superior digital forgeries," says Daryl Plummer, group vice president and chief fellow at Gartner. "Approaches to document verification, privacy legislation, digital rights management and protection of intellectual property will need to be revolutionised over time."

Gartner analysts say current laws are inadequate to halt abuses. For example, counterfeit reality is having a significant impact on virtual child pornography. The US supreme court turned back efforts by congress to outlaw the creation and distribution of simulated child pornography in a May 2002 ruling. The supreme court ruled that banning any image that appeared to be a child engaged in nude or lascivious acts was infringing on free speech and 'akin to prohibiting dirty thoughts'.

"The existing law puts the burden of proof on the government to prove that these children are real when a computer can easily alter their appearance with just a few keystrokes," Plummer says.

There have been many recent examples of counterfeit reality. Some of these include:

* A fake photograph of John Kerry together with Jane Fonda at an anti-Vietnam War rally in 1970 in Pennsylvania. The photograph angered veterans who said his association with her 34 years ago was a slap in the face of Vietnam War veterans. However, the picture was a hoax. While this has been proved false, the image fulfilled its intent to portray Kerry as an anti-military service candidate.

* Ben Vanderford created a video that depicted himself being beheaded and then forwarded the video to a known Islamic terrorist website. The website contacted various media outlets and within a few hours, major news organisations were reporting another beheading in Iraq. While the FBI is investigating Vanderford, it is unknown what charges he may face.

"Fake reality for sale will be the norm in the next decade. Surprisingly, its growth will not be about technology, but it will be about society's propensity for allowing the deviant to become the norm," Plummer says. "As people come to expect the use of virtual technology instead of realtime human interaction, the psychological outrage expected with counterfeit reality will be diminished."

For more information contact Gillian Dolby, Gartner Africa, 021 790 3526,

Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Online fleet management system
Issue 1 2020 , News
Fleet Domain’s online Fleet Management Information System is reducing operating costs and improving safety for South African logistics firms.

Digital insurance bundle for assets and devices
Issue 1 2020 , News
My CyberCare is a specialist provider of personal, and SMME online cyber insurance, cyber detection and cyber monitoring solutions for both local and global consumption.

IDEMIA to supply Morocco’s national electronic ID cards
Issue 1 2020, IDEMIA , News
IDEMIA will supply Morocco with national electronic ID cards and introduce a secured digital identity online services platform.

Rockwell Automation to acquire Avnet
Issue 1 2020, Rockwell Automation , News
Rockwell Automation announced it has signed an agreement to acquire privately held Avnet Data Security, an Israeli-based cybersecurity provider with over 20 years’ experience providing cybersecurity services.

Do we really want simplicity?
Issue 1 2020, Technews Publishing , News
Everything today has to be simple, easy and fast. Even access to your bank account has to fit these adjectives and banks spend significant time and money trying to ensure their web and mobile interfaces ...

Longse Distribution to become LD Africa
Issue 1 2020, LD Africa , News
Brendon Whelan, sales manager for Longse Distribution, announced that the company officially changed its name to LD Africa as of 20 January 2020.

Three expos in one
Issue 1 2020 , News
Looking ahead to 2020 Vision: combined Securex South Africa, A-OSH EXPO and Facilities Management Expo 2020 promises to be even bigger and better.

Security events you can’t miss in 2020
Issue 1 2020, Technews Publishing , News
Hi-Tech Security Solutions will host a number of focused events in 2020 to highlight the latest in security technology and the operational benefits they deliver.

David Shapiro to chair ESDA
Issue 1 2020, ESDA (Electronic Security Distributors Association , News
The Electronic Security Distributors’ Association (ESDA), established in 1989, has elected David Shapiro as its chairperson for 2020.

Dimension Data debuts fifth business
Issue 1 2020 , News
Dimension Data has launched its fifth business in the MEA region, Dimension Data Security, aimed at helping organisations in the region address the challenges of today’s rapidly evolving threat landscape.