Integrated security management systems - the benefits and pitfalls

March/April 2000 Integrated Solutions

Many articles have been written over the past three years on the subject of system integration. Having fallen asleep or screwed up the editorial in a rage half way through most, I find myself actually writing one! I hope that I am able to bring an alternative perspective to the subject through personal, and again another confession, bitter/pleasureable experience in integrating many systems over the last seven years. Coming from a technical background, the aim of this article is to give a 'no frills' account of what is possible both technically and practicably.

What is an integrated system?

The security equipment market has woken up to the benefits of integrating the components within a security system, but not all manufacturers can offer true integration. Consequently, the word 'integrated' is much sort after but much abused. So what does it really mean?

Some people use the term 'integrated' to describe a multiplexer combining full screen and multi screen images. Or a control desk containing an integrated intruder alarm PC, an integrated fence alarm PC and an integrated CCTV PC sitting next to one another. This is not true integration.

A true integrated system will combine these components, but as part of a larger, more sophisticated system. You might combine access control, fire alarms, intruder alarms, fence alarms, CCTV, public address system, and paging all within one system. To single PC or multi-station networks. These systems may be from differing manufacturers, they may be existing or new.

These individual components must interact with each other as one entity. For example, when a fire alarm is activated, the touch-screen VDU will display a text window to the operator giving full instruction on what to do. At the same time the system could automatically page staff, display the relevant CCTV cameras to view the area, release fire exit doors and the system will open a direct speech-path to the incident area, allowing the operator to communicate with staff, without having to manually select a public address system.

How to integrate systems

Systems can be integrated in many different ways dependant on the equipment and on the level of security required.

The easiest method of integration is by the use of voltage free inputs/outputs. One of the most reliable methods of achieving this is by the use on an RS485 I/O network(s) that can be transmitted up to 1 km or over fibre for the longer distances. This method is relatively competitive and can combine many different signals from various systems on one network.

Serial connection to a computer is by far the most common way of communicating with OEM (original equipment manufacturer) equipment. This method is fast, reliable and much more flexible than I/O. Information can be passed between OEM equipment and the system integrator with hand shaking (in many cases) to ensure that the alarm has been received. Whenever protocols have to be forthcoming from OEM(s), in my experience this has not been an issue, but some manufacturers are very cautious to whom they release this information. If you are a competitor it is almost impossible.

Even when protocol has been received 90% of the time it is either incorrect, incomplete or even misleading! It is essential to test product before installation, I know it is an old fashioned idea but it is really nice to see the system actually working.

If a higher security application is required, one must consider the use of serial hubs before using a server-based system. Servers are great, you can use dual mirrored hard drives, dual power supplies etc. But what happens when a surge occurs and destroys your multi-port serial card, serial connections do not like being switched and how does the software know where to address the information?

Serial to Ethernet converters

In theory it appears as if all these options are possible to achieve (no matter how difficult) but the practical side of dealing with 'on line' equipment via serial connections and server technology makes this complex in the extreme. Therefore, why not use the simpler option - serial to Ethernet converters?

Fast, reliable, easily replaced, low cost and they communicate with more than one computer to achieve transparent hot reserve (ie if one PC fails another takes over transparently but with a warning telling the operator to call the maintenance contractor). If one serial link causes a problem then only one OEM system is affected and the remainder of the integrated package remains intact.

One should always look for the simplest method of achieving integration that complies with the system requirements. Someone has to maintain these systems and others have to work with them. Faults need to be resolved quickly and easily keeping systems simple helps!

So what are the benefits?

Benefits are only achieved when the system has been designed properly. The most important element to any system no matter how complex or well designed is the ease of operation. One must consider who is actually going to be using the system. If the system is too complex or if it difficult to use or even if you can open boxes on boxes it will never work the operators will see to that!

The system must think for the operator and present information to them when required. This information must be clear and precise instructing the operators/security officers to carry out the necessary actions for any one scenario. The more actions the system can action automatically the better - no one works well under stressful conditions. If the operator knows that the system has reacted they can concentrate on their own task therefore reducing the stress factor.

When a system has been designed well, efficiency is improved dramatically. Reducing losses, damage, vandalism, cleaning costs, void offices/dwellings and man hours lost due to injury to staff represent some of the ways cost savings can be achieved. Sometimes a reduction in staffing levels (the most obvious cost saving) is not the best way. Tackling the problem must come first and can even pay for itself. Having an effective and efficient backup can be crucial, dispatching staff immediately to the breach in security.

One can liken a good integrated system to a rugby team. If you could pick the ideal team from around the world, each player would be outstanding in there own right, they would bring a unique element onto the field. Individually they are superior in their field but put together as a team, interacting with one another, the effective enhancement is too difficult to quantify.

Pitfalls

The easiest mistake for an engineer to make is designing a system that becomes too difficult for an operator to use. Do not introduce systems that are of no practical benefit to the security system.

For example using a BMS (building management system) to give an input on an alarm such as a boiler failure is of benefit. But to allow the operator to control the temperature of the water in the swimming pool is complex and has no real benefit. Do not use the system just because it is there.

Each system must work independently and must not be reliant on the integrated control system. Keyboards, panels, controllers must be available – no system is 100% foolproof.

Total cost of ownership

Perhaps one of the hidden areas is the cost of expansion in the future. This can double or even triple the initial system costs. The client must be fully aware of the overall costs for their project, including costs for future system expansion. Also detailed performance specification should be written or obtained for any 'special' items or bespoke operation.

This is time consuming but crucial to have clarification in writing before commencement of the project. It is so often expressed by clients, 'That is not what I wanted or even asked for'. Clarification is essential, as interpretation can occur on different levels.

The key to any successful project is planning at all stages and co-operation from all parties. Confirmed information is essential as is pre-testing before delivery onto site.



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Building a nervous system for smart cities
Issue 1 2020, Pinnacle Instruments SA , Integrated Solutions
Build a central nervous system for smart cities, by employing real-time situation reporting and analysis that unites the powers of cloud computing, AI, IoT and big data.

Read more...
The secret to 5G security? Turn the network into a sensor
Issue 1 2020 , Integrated Solutions
We are about to make the leap from being a civilisation that uses networks to one that runs on them in a fundamental and inextricable way.

Read more...
The move to services and RMR
Issue 1 2020, Merchant West, G4S South Africa, Technews Publishing , Integrated Solutions
Project work used to be the staple diet for system integrators, but that was before the services model changed the way businesses buy and use their security systems.

Read more...
Global security industry adopts servistisation models
Issue 1 2020 , Integrated Solutions
New as-a-service business models are gaining traction because they reduce capital expenditure and cost of ownership, finds Frost & Sullivan.

Read more...
Looking ahead with mobile access technologies
Access & Identity Management Handbook 2020, Technews Publishing, HID Global, dormakaba South Africa, Salto Systems Africa, Suprema, Gallagher , Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions
Given the broad use of smartphones around the world and the numerous technologies packed into these devices, it was only a matter of time before the access control industry developed technology that would ...

Read more...
Scalable access solution
Access & Identity Management Handbook 2020 , Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions
Bosch Building Technologies makes access management simple, scalable and always available with Access Management System 2.0.

Read more...
Securing perimeters of secure locations
November 2019, Axis Communications SA, Modular Communications, Hikvision South Africa, Nemtek Electric Fencing Products, Technews Publishing, Stafix , Government and Parastatal (Industry), Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, Integrated Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked a number of companies offering perimeter security solutions for their insights into protecting the boundaries of national key points.

Read more...
The safe city and its need for interoperability
November 2019 , Integrated Solutions, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
Interoperability continues to present one of the greatest challenges, particularly with video management systems, video recording devices and cameras.

Read more...
Analytics-driven solutions for smart infrastructure
November 2019, Bosch Building Technologies , Integrated Solutions
Video analytics technology can bring intelligence to infrastructure by delivering solutions for traffic flow, improved safety, smart parking, and data collection.

Read more...
A platform approach to innovation and value
CCTV Handbook 2019, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Integrated Solutions, IT infrastructure
Moving to the platform model of doing business holds tremendous advantages for end users and smaller developers, but also for the whole technology supply chain.

Read more...