How digital signal processing is improving outdoor intrusion detection

March/April 2000 Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection

The past decade has seen incredible leaps in out door security alarm reporting. Regardless of the technology, the following questions had to be answered before the newest breakthrough could be employed:

* Is the probability of detection high?

* At what point can the technology be defeated?

* Does it provide a high or low false/nuisance alarm rate?

* Are we better off adding this technology or should the same money be spent to bolster what we already have?

Sophisticated outdoor products that meet exacting performance criteria typically are accompanied with higher price tags. Nonetheless, even some of these premium priced products still lack the dynamic ranges necessary to distinguish actual intrusions from nuisance alarms. At the same time, lower cost products tend to offer a lesser probability of detection and trigger increased alarms, seemingly at will. What's the problem? The great outdoors itself. Products created for indoor applications won't necessarily be successful outdoors.

The outdoor environment

The outdoor environment presents a complex series of conditions that indoor-based electronics gear finds adverse - temperature extremes, rain, fog, snow, animals, wind, debris, traffic, seismic effects and the nature of the terrain above and below ground. Combine a few of these conditions and the problems become even more acute. One plus one equals three when working outdoors.

DSP to the rescue

New microprocessors now permit Digital Signal Processing (DSP) at the alarm itself. DSP uses multiple parameters to better discriminate between real intruders and environmental effects. This yields more dynamic, intelligent interpretations of sensor signals. DSP helps the system determine that a rabbit isn't a vandal and a bird is not a thief.

You will find DSP used to greatest advantage in the alarm processor. Veterans of the security wars will remember that older analog units attempt to average background signal changes to establish a base for thresholding. Once the background activity reaches a certain level, the thresholds are 'gearshifted' to some higher value in order to compensate. When background activity decreases, the base level requires time to adjust. Thus, sensor sensitivity is compromised.

However with DSP, the background is evaluated on a dynamic, ongoing basis. Thresholds are adjusted continuously to maintain the same sensitivity within a dynamically changing background. Because of this, performance is not compromised. There are fancy names for this such as 'Ambient Compensation' and 'Dynamic Thresholding'. They both mean that the system will know a rabbit is a rabbit and a bird is a bird or, conversely, neither the rabbit nor bird is an intruder.

From a technology sense, this isn't necessarily new. Indoor intrusion units have exploited DSP for some time. However, research in developing sensors for the outdoors finds that signal characteristics for intrusions differ significantly from wind, rain and other natural phenomena - dynamics that can be ignored indoors.

Now, new systems can handle these dynamics outdoors. Today's DSP distinguishes these outdoor events, something that causes great difficulties for those older analogue filters. With DSP, you obtain better detection and fewer false alarms. In addition, the problems of processor drift with time and variation of output signal strength within the sensor environment are things of the past.

Even more advantages come to the forefront when using DSP in dual zone processors. Now, by comparing the ambient signals in both zones, the processor can even better identify common effects caused by the environment. There's a fancy name for this, too. It is called 'common mode rejection'. It helps reduce nuisance alarms.

For those that want to really go techie

DSP is only the beginning of new outdoor intrusion detection technologies. The processing used for detecting intruders in the outdoors is also more sophisticated. Instead of only looking for a simple change in signal amplitude, a digital processor analyses a complex signal consisting of amplitude changes (ie mass of the intruder), rate of signal change (ie movement of the intruder) and the time the intruder is in the detection field, along with other parameters. In other words, the system is now saying, "If the disturbance is the size of an intruder, has the movements of an intruder and is taking the time required for an intruder to intrude, we just might have an intruder out there. We don't have a rabbit or a bird."

Digitisation also means that alarm and sensor data can now be sent over a twisted copper pair of wire or fibre optic data network. Today, alarm information is typically sent to a central location. The network itself can then be used to monitor sensor performance, give a dynamic display of sensor operation at the central station and, when necessary, adjust the thresholds of each sensor zone separately.

Benefits are far ranging

To optimise sensor performance, the display terminal at the central station has replaced the chart recorder or digital voltmeter used in the field. Since data is now easy to obtain, technicians no longer must be so intensively trained. That saves money and eliminates human mistakes.

Sensor performance can also be communicated directly and completely by data transmission via a phone line. Through clever, patented use of bandwidth properties, it is now possible to use the sensor cables themselves to detect intruders, send power to each processor and transmit information on a data network to a central alarm display and maintenance unit.

Yes, digital technology is now greatly enhancing the performance of outdoor perimeter security sensors. These sensors can be quickly configured when added to data networks in a plug-and-play fashion. They are immediately recognised by the system.

For details contact Martin Kelly of Senstar-Stellar on tel: (0944) 1386-834433 or e-mail:

Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Watch your perimeter
Access & Identity Management Handbook 2020 , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
SqwidNet collaborated with Teqcon, a South African mechanical and electronic design company, to address the problem of perimeter security in remote locations.

Compact outdoor PIRs
Issue 4 2020 , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
OPTEX launches ITS QXI series of double-layered, compact outdoor, high-mount PIRs in EMEA.

The end of blind alarms
Issue 3 2020 , Security Services & Risk Management, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Today’s alarms should be supplemented by visual verification to ensure that guards are not dispatched to false alarms, wasting time and money.

Pima’s Force Series
Issue 3 2020, Technews Publishing , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Pima recently launched its latest alarm system, the Force Series into the South African market.

Thermal products for perimeter protection
Issue 3 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
The latest generation of thermal cameras from Hikvision make it faster and easier for small and medium businesses to secure their perimeter.

MotionProtect outdoor security
Issue 3 2020, Powell Tronics , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
JAX offers outdoor security through its MotionProtect Outdoor, a motion detector with a two-phase algorithm for protection against false triggering and pet immunity.

New alarm solutions
Issue 2 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Hikvision has created a broad portfolio of alarm solutions that are sophisticated, automated, and fit for purpose.

Video and audio convergence
Issue 1 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Hikvision has introduced its video and audio convergence solution to the market, featuring an innovative real-time intrusion deterrent feature.

Securing perimeters of secure locations
November 2019, Axis Communications SA, Modular Communications, Hikvision South Africa, Nemtek Electric Fencing Products, Technews Publishing, Stafix , Government and Parastatal (Industry), Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, Integrated Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked a number of companies offering perimeter security solutions for their insights into protecting the boundaries of national key points.

Utility outages: Are you looking at the big picture?
October 2019 , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
We have to start thinking about, and laying plans for, the real possibility that the whole grid is somehow compromised.