A real security solution

January 2013 Security Services & Risk Management

I want to tell you a story about why an independent security risk assessment is different from a risk assessment done by a security provider.

Andre Mundell
Andre Mundell

A few years back a new client phoned us with a recurring problem. Criminals had captured one of the guards on the premises and used his radio to establish the whereabouts of the rest of the security team. After capturing the entire security staff, they had been able to rob the company of assets worth thousands.

The client had switched security providers only to have this scenario repeated another four times. Each of these security providers had ostensibly performed a security risk assessment on the property, but they had all recommended solutions which matched the services and products that they offered rather than tailoring solutions to their client’s needs.

We were then asked to do a security risk assessment on the premises in question.

After identifying all the relevant issues the client finally understood how and where the criminals were gaining access to the property and came to the following conclusions:

* The previous security companies had not considered effective lighting options.

* They had not considered thermal products while the neighbourhood and premises itself were very dark, and some of these security providers did not even know the basics of how thermal products work.

Because of the size and layout of the premises, we suggested the following:

* That their security service provider (Company A) be retained and allowed inside the premises.

* Because of the fact that criminals always managed to overpower and take these guards captive, we recommended that another security service provider (Company B), be placed on the outside of the premises in plain clothes.

After a few months, the same criminals attacked the client’s premises again. Company A had not been made aware of Company B, and there was no radio link between the two. This meant that the criminals also had no knowledge of Company B. Company B saw the guards from Company A being overpowered, reacted accordingly by informing the SAPS and their own armed reaction vehicles and in the end, the criminals were apprehended.

The above is a classic example of why security service providers cannot do security risk assessments, and also why they cannot tell you when they find risks that cannot be handled by one of their services or products. Hence the fact that it is imperative that companies employ the services of independent security risk assessors who will suggest real solutions to eliminate the client’s security risks as identified and explained in the final assessment. This in turn will allow the client to ensure that those risks are properly addressed as per the solutions suggested in the security plan.

No security company will advise a client to hire their competition to protect one area while they themselves protect another. Being independent and unaffiliated we were able to see the real risks involved and made solution based suggestions based on the client’s individual and working environment security needs.

It is better that a security risk assessment is done by an independent security risk assessor. Assessors cannot do an objective security risk assessment or ensure relevant and correct solutions if they are affiliated to any security provider or supplier.

Companies requesting security usually assume that their appointed security provider has done a security risk assessment; and most security providers will say that they have done a risk assessment. However, they will have performed a product assessment, not a security risk assessment. Security providers cannot and in most cases will not reveal your true risks to you.

I would like to stress to all corporate MDs, CEOs and small business owners the importance of protecting your company’s assets and employees. Gather all your facts before accepting any proposal for security services or products.

I again want to emphasise the fact that security providers and suppliers are not equipped to do security risk assessments. The fact that they are mandated to perform any and all assessments to reflect their service or product as the best option for you restricts them from being able to do effective and objective security risk assessments.

For more information contact Alwinco, +27 (0)71 319 4735, aviljoen@alwinco.co.za, www.alwinco.co.za





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Communication in any situation
Issue 8 2020, Elvey Security Technologies , Global Communications , Security Services & Risk Management
Global Communications offers an industry-first with five-year warranty on select Kenwood two-way radios.

Read more...
The year resilience paid off
Issue 8 2020 , Editor's Choice, Security Services & Risk Management
Hi-Tech Security Solutions spoke to Michael Davies about business continuity and resilience in a year when everything was put to the test.

Read more...
The reality of farm attacks
Issue 3 2021, Technews Publishing , Security Services & Risk Management
Nowhere in the world are people being as brutally attacked and murdered like farmers in South Africa (including a number of black emerging farmers and black farm labourers that have been attacked and injured or killed).

Read more...
Insights into PoPIA compliance
Issue 3 2021, Technews Publishing , Security Services & Risk Management
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked Carrie Peter, solution owner at Impression Signatures, for a few insights on what this piece of legislation means in the real world.

Read more...
Top 10 security misperceptions
Issue 3 2021 , Cyber Security, Security Services & Risk Management
The Sophos Rapid Response team has compiled a list of the most commonly held security misperceptions they’ve encountered in the last 12 months while neutralising and investigating cyberattacks in a wide range of organisations.

Read more...
The supply chain of the future
Issue 3 2021 , Integrated Solutions, Security Services & Risk Management, Retail (Industry)
For retailers to maximise their bottom line, the supply chain needs to be fast, efficient and responsive, which requires the use of intelligent, integrated technology.

Read more...
PoPIA: Time Is up
Issue 3 2021 , Security Services & Risk Management, IT infrastructure
The Protection of Personal Information Act (PoPIA) comes into full effect on 1 July 2021 and there remains much confusion and ambiguity regarding its definitions, requirements and enforcement.

Read more...
Anomaly detection is the first layer
Issue 3 2021 , Security Services & Risk Management
A multi-layered, proactive approach to data management and protection is essential and this begins with anomaly detection as the first line of defence.

Read more...
Towards a cashless world
Issue 3 2021 , Security Services & Risk Management
In addition to being safer from a viral transmission perspective, contactless payment is also faster and integrating multiple contactless payment methods assists small businesses to better maintain financial liquidity.

Read more...
mySOS targets neighbourhood safety
Issue 2 2021 , Security Services & Risk Management
Beyond protection for valuables and premises, people are also looking to ensure their personal safety and that of their loved ones as they move around and within community areas.

Read more...