Multiple methods for motion detection

Residential Estate Security Handbook 2019 Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection

There are many different options for motion detection, but which one best suits your needs? Here I look at some of the most widely used motion sensor technologies and explore the situations in which each can be used to its strengths.

An important and often overlooked factor when choosing new components for your security system is how well they will integrate with your existing network. Security systems are at their most effective when made up of a collection of best-in-breed components working seamlessly together. So, before deciding on a new component for your system, ask yourself how it will fit into your existing network and whether it will work with components you might want to add in the future.

It is also worth noting that within the motion detection technologies I’ll be looking at, there will be significant differences in quality and effectiveness between individual products. The below is aimed at differentiating between the benefits of each technology when operating in the most appropriate environment.

Finally, and most importantly, choose a solution that fits the specific job. Every installation will come with its own challenges – be they budget constraints or challenging conditions – and each will require a tailored solution to meet the requirements.

PIR sensors

Passive infrared (PIR) sensors pick up heat signatures from objects within their field of view. The sensor detects changes in the amount of infrared radiation it picks up, and when a threshold limit is reached the sensor will trigger whatever it is connected to – be it a light, alarm or camera. (Wikipedia has more on PIRs at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_infrared_sensor.)

This simple technology is effective in what it does, but the simplicity of the design brings with it inherent problems. For one, the output from the sensor is a very simple yes/no (e.g. switch the light on or don’t). The significance of this will become apparent when compared to alternative technology in this post. In addition, the way in which the PIR sensor operates also means that it doesn’t have the greatest range, and it can easily fall foul of obstructions (e.g. spider webs, leaves etc.) and passing heat signatures (e.g. Garfield, Peter Rabbit, Fantastic Mr. Fox etc.) that will trigger false alarms.

Negatives aside, PIR sensors are effective provided you are aware of their limitations. They work well in smaller indoor areas and don’t ‘see’ through windows – a problem sometimes encountered by video motion detection. And, given that they have been used in security systems for so long, they are also fairly affordable. As mentioned previously, there will be differences between PIR sensors at different ends of the market – make sure you choose one that suits your specific needs.

Video motion detection (VMD)

The VMD option combines the images generated by a security camera, with software that can analyse the images as they are captured. This takes place in much the same way as a camera operator sitting watching a video feed, but is automated and as such holds certain advantages. (More on VMD can be found at https://www.axis.com/blog/secure-insights/recognize-a-threat/.)

It is easy to visualise some of the downsides of this technology. Operating in the visible light spectrum, the camera is blind if there is not enough light, and open to blinding if there is too much backlighting. Even if using a sensor-activated light there will always be the problem of shadows. On the upside, video is a widely implemented security solution and adding a layer of analytics is fairly cost-effective.

This method of motion detection relies heavily on two key components: the quality of the image from the camera and the quality of the analytics software in use. There are a wide range of VMD technologies out there – some will allow you to make tweaks to settings, e.g. to only detect motion within certain perimeters, and some will simply detect any movement. Again, it is important to choose equipment that is suited to the situation in which it will be used.

Thermal cameras

First things first, thermal cameras are not really cameras in that they don’t pick up visible light. To oversimplify, they are sensors that create an image based on temperature differences between objects in their ‘field of vision’. You can learn more about thermal cameras at https://www.axis.com/blog/secure-insights/thermal-cameras/.

Thermal cameras are marvellous pieces of kit. They have an excellent range, even if they do focus on a fairly narrow area, can pick up heat signatures through smoke and fog and are immune to many conditions that would be problematic to visible light cameras – shadows, darkness, backlight and even camouflaged objects. They also work with video analytics as described above, and are particularly effective when used in tandem with visible light cameras.

Whilst these thermal imaging cameras are highly effective, they do come with a similarly high price tag which can put the technology out of bounds in many cases.

Radar

To oversimplify once more, radar works by transmitting radio waves and receiving the same waves bounced off objects in its field of detection. For an in-depth explanation, check out the Wikipedia entry at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar. In terms of usefulness in a security system, this technology calculates distance, velocity and size of objects in relation to the detector.

The benefit of using radio waves over infrared or visible light is a comparative lack of interference caused by day-to-day obstructions or false alarms. Radio waves pass through unsubstantial objects such as spider webs, leaves and smoke, allowing radar equipment to focus on objects of significance. They also operate independently of the visible light spectrum, and thus work unimpeded by difficult light conditions.

A particular advantage of tracking the distance of objects is that radar can be set to operate within specific zones, for example within a fenced off area – again reducing false alarms from activity outside the perimeter. In addition, it can detect motion across a far wider area than thermal cameras even if it does so over a shorter range. Radar comes in at a price well below that of thermal cameras and not far off PIR sensors.

Situation-specific solutions

There are strengths and weaknesses to go with all these motion detection solutions, and their effectiveness will be dictated by the situations in which they are used and the additional components that they are being used with. A visible light camera would be useless at night on its own, but the addition of a motion sensor-triggered light would vastly improve performance; you probably wouldn’t install an elaborate radar in a 4x4-metre office; and a PIR sensor would be of little use detecting intruders in a wildlife sanctuary (unless you wanted to detect wildlife).

For more information contact Axis Communications, +27 11 548 6780, sasha.bonheim@axis.com, www.axis.com



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Retail solutions beyond security
Issue 8 2020, Axis Communications SA, Technews Publishing, Hikvision South Africa , Editor's Choice, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
The need for security technology to deliver more than videos of people falling or stealing from retail stores is greater than ever.

Read more...
AX PRO wireless alarm solutions
Issue 8 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, Products
Hikvision announced its new generation of wireless alarm systems – the AX PRO – delivering comprehensive alarm solutions for both residential and commercial applications.

Read more...
Improving patient care
Issue 2 2021, Axis Communications SA , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Healthcare (Industry)
Nemours Children’s Health System has installed Axis network video cameras in every patient room to improve patient care to avoid nuisance alarms.

Read more...
Continual electric fence monitoring
Issue 2 2021 , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, Residential Estate (Industry)
In today’s security conscious world, one of the top priorities of residential estate living is ensuring that the electric fence is always operational.

Read more...
Integrate wired and wireless alarms
Issue 2 2021, Regal Distributors SA , Products, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
The Ajax MultiTransmitter enables customers to upgrade and tap into the wireless Ajax network with an existing wired alarm system, making it a hybrid system.

Read more...
Access control during a health crisis
Issue 2 2021, Axis Communications SA , Healthcare (Industry)
Preventing the transmission of coronavirus in healthcare settings is obviously critical. Paul Baratta discusses access control and how it can help healthcare providers today and well into the future.

Read more...
New rapid deploy virtual perimeter system released
Issue 2 2021 , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
PureTech Systems today announced the release of the PureActiv Rapid Deploy Virtual Perimeter, a fully autonomous system that can protect small and large perimeters at significantly less cost than hard-wired solutions.

Read more...
Third-party integration into Ajax
Issue 2 2021, Regal Distributors SA , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
The Ajax Transmitter offers you an easy and affordable wireless solution to help you integrate third-party wireless detectors into Ajax.

Read more...
Intelligent detectors protect terracotta warriors
Issue 2 2021, Bosch Building Technologies , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Bosch intrusion alarm solution secures UNESCO World Heritage Site with Sensor Data Fusion technology, including several hundred TriTech motion detectors with passive infrared (PIR) sensors and microwave Doppler radar detection technology.

Read more...
Regal to distribute Ajax Systems
Issue 1 2021, Regal Distributors SA , Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Regal Distributors has announced that it is now one of the master distributors of Ajax Systems in South Africa, and believes the partnership with Ajax will enable it to make a greater impact in the electronic security market.

Read more...