Letter to the editor

October 2018 Associations, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection

We refer to an article published in your August 2018 edition, namely “The alarming disadvantages of home security systems”, written by Meraj Hoda, vice president of Ring Inc.

The content of this article begs the question as to whether your editorial team actually read the submitted articles prior to publication and understand the implications of supporting such statements in a publication such as yours.

As this is clearly the case, allow me to explain what this article implies.

The writer has in a single article, discredited the entire worldwide multi-billion Rand highly technological intruder alarm industry as outdated, ineffective and inefficient, to quote just a few of his choice of words. He has also discounted the need for armed response.

All of this in a weak and desperate attempt to market a ‘gimmick’, which, in a professional industry such as ours, would be referred to as a ‘DIY supermarket’ product.

This product is the “Video Doorbell”, which Mr Hoda claims is the answer to crime in South Africa and a suitable replacement to sophisticated intruder alarm systems.

If Mr Hoda had taken the time to visit and research the South African residential security market, he might have noticed that we do not have ‘doorbells’ due to the fact that our high walls and electric fencing do not allow anyone to get to the front door.

Mr Hoda naïvely suggests that criminals will often knock on the door or ring the doorbell before attempting to break in. Unlike the UK or the US, South Africa has a unique crime footprint which is a far cry from our overseas counterparts. Our criminals do not politely ring the doorbell before they break in.

They break the door down!

In fact, this ‘doorbell’ is more likely to be stolen.

We challenge Mr Hoda to disarm a correctly installed ‘professional’ intruder alarm system, which as claimed in his article, “burglars have learned how to disarm them”.

In conclusion, we consider this article to be misleading to the public, negligent, unprofessional and totally without merit or proper research. If anything, this ‘false security’ will put the lives of the public in danger.

As an association and in the interests of the public and professional security, we request that you publish this response and retract the article in its current form.

South African Intruder Detection Services Association (SAIDSA).

Editor’s response

For any readers not familiar with the article, it can be found at www.securitysa.com/60672n

In response to the SAIDSA comments, there are some aspects I would like to highlight.

In the first instance, SAIDSA is 100% correct, a doorbell, even a video doorbell, would provide limited security and only in a fraction of the intrusion cases we face in South Africa. As a South African and the editor of a security publication I am only too aware of the challenges we face and would never suggest this is all you require for security; if that is the impression the article leaves then my editing job was poorly done for which I apologise.

I have met Mr Hoda on one of his trips to South Africa and can attest to his knowledge of the rampant crime situation in the country.

The size of the security industry in South Africa is proof of its necessity as well as its general effectiveness. Nobody is claiming alarm systems installed by SAIDSA members are inferior, but we should also remember that not every installer is a member and the quality of the work and products used may not always live up to the standards SAIDSA promotes.

We also have an enormous number of people in this country that can’t afford to install an alarm and pay for an armed response service. For these people a ‘DIY supermarket product’ is the best they can do. Furthermore, Ring offers a range of products that can all be integrated into a security solution.

Neither Hi-Tech Security Solutions nor Mr Hoda suggest people do away with their alarms and intrusion detection, however there are many places where the Ring products can be used successfully, such as residential estates, apartments and even standalone houses. With visual verification becoming more popular, this is one product that can assist in verifying an alarm and reducing false alarm callouts.

If Hi-Tech Security Solutions created the impression that this one product does away with the need for alarms and intrusion prevention, as well as security services, we apologise as that is definitely not the case.

Ring will respond in the next issue.

Andrew Seldon.



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Leaders in risk and security: As long as there are people, there will be risk
Issue 5 2020, iFacts, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Jenny Reid is a self-made success, focusing on people, the risks they create and the potential they have.

Read more...
Mitigating the human risk
Issue 5 2020, Managed Integrity Evaluation, Technews Publishing, iFacts , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked Jennifer Barkhuizen and Jenny Reid for some information around background screening and vetting of potential new hires.

Read more...
XProtect available on AWS
Issue 5 2020, Milestone Systems, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Milestone recently announced the availability of XProtect on Amazon Web Services. Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked Keven Marier for more information.

Read more...
Adjusting to a new reality
Issue 5 2020, Technews Publishing , Integrated Solutions
COVID-19 to accelerate adoption of technology-enabled smart city resilience approaches: robotics, digital twins, and autonomous freight.

Read more...
From the editor's desk: We're back!
Issue 5 2020, Technews Publishing , News
Welcome to the fifth issue of 2020. If years were people, 2020 would have been hung, drawn and quartered...

Read more...
From the editor’s desk: Sustaining security and sanity
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2020, Technews Publishing , News
Sustainability is a critical component of almost anything in these days of a tanking economy, boosted by COVID-19, which is given further emphasis by the economy being further hammered by the ‘cure’ for ...

Read more...
The COVID test for estate business continuity planning
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2020, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Many estates were caught unaware when the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdown hit. Helderberg Village was ready for the challenge.

Read more...
More efficient guarding through the effective use of technology
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2020, Technews Publishing, OnGuard, Stallion Security, Active Track , Security Services & Risk Management
Technology in its many forms can be used to optimise the efficiency and performance of on-site guarding.

Read more...
Focus on touchless biometrics
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2020, Hikvision South Africa, Saflec, IDEMIA , Suprema, Technews Publishing , Access Control & Identity Management
The coronavirus has made touchless biometrics an important consideration for access control installations in estates and for industries globally.

Read more...
Residential Estate Security Conference 2020
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2020, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Back in the old days when conferences that people attended in a single location were a thing, Hi-Tech Security Solutions held its Residential Estate Security Conference 2020 at the Durban Country Club.

Read more...