classic | mobile
Follow us on:
Follow us on Facebook  Share via Twitter  Share via LinkedIn

Hi-Tech Security Solutions Business Directory
Residential Estate Security Handbook 2018

Technology risk assessments
August 2018, This Week's Editor's Pick, Security Services & Risk Management, Residential Estate (Industry)

In all cases, whether formally or informally, the security operation is developed around understanding the risks in each situation we face. When an incident takes place, the risk becomes more defined and the security plan is adjusted accordingly.

Rob Anderson, Adamastor Consulting.
Rob Anderson, Adamastor Consulting.

It is unfortunate that this adjustment is mostly undertaken as an emotional and reactionary response rather than a calm analysis of facts and a follow-on solution. An example would be a first reaction to a burglar finding a weak link in the physical security of the estate. Those in charge would be embarrassed that it could have occurred at all, and a great deal of rushing around would take place to fix the problem. It is understandable, and it is human nature.

This is all to do with monitoring risk, associated with the barriers and physical security that you can see. We can all see a hole in the fence, but this is the age where so much of the security operation relies on electronics. The ‘holes’ are embedded in the electronic systems. The electronics reduces costs, and if correctly implemented, should introduce efficiencies into the system. However, how do we know when a ‘hole’ develops or a loophole in the electronics is found by one whose intentions are not good?

It is important to realise there is a risk associated with the electronic solution as well. This can only be detected by the technology team, but their focus and training is electronics and they are not necessarily security risk experts.

Physical and technology risks

This leads to the point that we should be undertaking security risk assessments that look not only at the physical elements, but the technical elements too. One of the very first examples, which criminals very soon took advantage of, was to move the obvious CCTV camera or place a hat over it. The evidence that the CCTV would have collected becomes unavailable. In response to this, many manufacturers added alarms to the signal stream from the camera. They were recorded as ‘Camera Moved’ or ‘No Video’, to alert the security personnel.

I am not sure if these alarms are still available. It remains a risk however, because in many cases a camera mounted in a lower position provides better surveillance. We are then back in the ‘easy to get to’ zone. This is perhaps a physical rather than an electronic risk, although it affects both solutions, but things have moved on from this start and criminals have become more sophisticated as technology progressed.

The question is now: How do we assess the risks in the technology solution? These risks can probably be divided into two types.

1. A system failure that was not expected and cannot have been predicted. There must be procedures in place to recognise this type of failure and have a planned response which can be speedily implemented.

2. A badly designed, installed or maintained system that is slowly or sometimes, quickly, heading for failure. These are usually more severe than the first one, as whole sections of the installation often need to be replaced.

The technology risk assessment

As an example, the technology risk assessment should be based on the evaluation of the following criteria:

1. What is the purpose of each component of the technology solution and is it performing the task required?

2. Has the system design covered all the eventualities?

3. Are all components of the electronic solution correctly installed, secure and being adequately maintained?

4. Is there any known method of by-passing the electronic system so that it is prevented from performing the task for with it was installed?

5. Are there documents available to assist technicians in fault finding and as an aid to understanding the functioning of the system?

6. Is there any information available from other estates where the same problem has arisen? This problem may have occurred before and a solution may be available.

It is clear, that assessing risk is important. The task is, however, of little benefit unless it is undertaken in a very structured manner. What would this be?

It is probably a good idea to start my making a check list for the full estate electronic security installation. The check list needs to address each of the systems and their component parts. In addition, it should look at the overall management of the technology solution. This would typically include reporting, maintenance, spares and system age. It could be that the electronics has reached to end-of-life stage. The list will grow as more assessments are done and it becomes clear that it would be beneficial to go into more detail. As the assessment takes place, each item will be categorised as follows:

1. All good

2. Problems detected

3. Have no idea

Clearly items 2 and 3 will require a decision to be made on the remedial measure and its implementation. If you have “no idea”, then an expert needs to be contacted to assist. This is often the case when you are considering items such as computer equipment, database management and protection against hacking threats to the system.

A structured approach

In following a structured approach and remedial treatment what sort of items should form part of the list? Some are listed as follows:

1. Does the control room check that all cameras are functioning and recording on every shift?

2. Is the backup of data taking place correctly every day?

3. Are all the backup power supplies healthy?

4. The after dark CCTV images should be checked. Are they good enough to be of value to the security operation?

5. Are the access control cameras all pointing in the right direction?

6. Are the cameras which have an analytics facility still operating as intended?

7. Is there still a voltage on the electric fence? If the energiser loses power does an alarm alert the control room?

8. Is the control room vulnerable to attack? This would include criminals easily taking over the control room. This becomes ever more important as criminals seem unafraid of using force.

9. Are all staff properly trained in the use of the electronic systems?

10. Undertake mock incidents and check if the systems function correctly, the staff respond correctly and the data can be interrogated to prepare a report.

The overall aim is to find out any possible reason for the technology system letting you down. As can be seen, this could be product failure, system design failure, lack of information available to maintain the system properly and lack of information to implement a recovery from a possible catastrophic failure.

The process must be ongoing, and the non-technical staff should become involved and take part. In this way they will become more valuable to the operation as they develop an understanding of the systems they are using.

Remember, you would not drive your car with tyres that are completely worn out. It is a terrible risk from all points of view. With this in mind, don’t run a security operation with all sorts of lurking risks.

  Share via Twitter   Share via LinkedIn      

Further reading:

  • Significant differences in ­perceptions on state of digital trust
    November 2018, CA Southern Africa, Access Control & Identity Management, Security Services & Risk Management
    Nearly half of businesses admit to selling customer data, despite claiming data ­protection as paramount; consumer behaviour shows strong correlation between loss of business and lack of digital trust.
  • Trust but continually verify
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions, IT infrastructure
    Hi-Tech Security Solutions looks at access and identity management and asks some industry players what ‘zero trust’ and ‘least privilege’ access means.
  • Managing who, what and why
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Cyber Security
    Today’s access control isn’t only concerned with who has access, but also what has access, why they need it and what they are doing with it.
  • Physical/logical convergence
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Cyber Security, Integrated Solutions, IT infrastructure
    The convergence between physical and logical (or cyber) security will be a game-changer because it will change the way we do everything, from planning to design and all the way to installation and maintenance.
  • Physical and logical convergence is a fact
    November 2018, This Week's Editor's Pick, Integrated Solutions, IT infrastructure
    Convergence, the next buzzword? A dated buzzword? Is convergence ­merely ­integration on steroids? What is convergence?
  • The expanding role of IT in access control
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management, IT infrastructure
    What role is IT playing in the world of physical access control and how far will its role expand in future?
  • Taking augmented identity to the world
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions
    Hi-Tech Security Solutions spoke to Gary Jones, VP Global Channel and Marketing biometric access and time solutions) at IDEMIA (formerly Morpho) about his career with the company and its new vision of Augmented Identity.
  • Tracking biometrics into a brave new digital world
    November 2018, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions
    The industry is increasingly transitioning from unimodal to more integrated multimodal biometric solutions for more accurate identity verification and faster real-time results.
  • A better approach to fingerprint biometrics
    November 2018, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management
    Not all optical biometric fingerprint scanners are created equal. The type of sensor used has a powerful impact on speed, accuracy, reliability and portability.
  • The right access decisions
    November 2018, Technews Publishing, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management
    Making the right access control decision depends on what you want secured and how secure it should be.
  • Reliability a fundamental in visitor management
    November 2018, Powell Tronics, Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions, Security Services & Risk Management
    With the rapid evolution of biometric technology, there are many options available in the marketplace that promise varying levels of performance.
  • Digital channels and the evolution of ID
    November 2018, This Week's Editor's Pick, Access Control & Identity Management, IT infrastructure
    While the concept of identity (ID) remains unchanged, the rapid evolution of digital technology has dramatically extended both its application and form factor.

Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd
1st Floor, Stabilitas House
265 Kent Ave, Randburg, 2194
South Africa
Publications by Technews
Dataweek Electronics & Communications Technology
Electronic Buyers Guide (EBG)

Hi-Tech Security Solutions
Hi-Tech Security Business Directory (HSBD)

Motion Control in Southern Africa
Motion Control Buyers’ Guide (MCBG)

South African Instrumentation & Control
South African Instrumentation & Control Buyers’ Guide (IBG)
Terms & conditions of use, including privacy policy
PAIA Manual
    Mobile | Classic

Copyright © Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved.