The future of Checkpoint Delta

Access & Identity Management Handbook 2017 Editor's Choice, Access Control & Identity Management, Transport (Industry)

For over half a century now, Checkpoint Charlie has captured our imagination as the ultimate border crossing. Shrouded in the mysteries of cold war espionage stories, when the Berlin wall finally came down, it had 14 checkpoints that went by the names of the neighbourhoods they were located in. But earlier, they simply bore signage in the aviator alphabet – Alpha, Bravo, Charlie … and of this somehow this makeshift name of the Friedrichstrasse crossing persisted, and even after being reduced to a mere tourist attraction, it remains a poignant reminder of one of the sad aspects of nation-state politics – that of dividing people from people.

Sanjay Dharwadker.
Sanjay Dharwadker.

At the beginning of the twenty-first century, this drama has shifted to the airport, and thus, if you deal in security policy, strategy or technology, it becomes a microcosm to be examined in great detail. No doubt, 9/11 or rather its immediate aftermath, has been the single most important reason for this focus.

However, the definitive ideas around it came together, with more clarity than anywhere else perhaps, in the book titled Politics at the Airport, edited by Mark B. Salter. Published in 2008, it is a slim volume, with just eight papers by different authors and comes in at under two hundred pages. Professor Salter teaches political science at the University of Ottawa. Not surprisingly, the most influential bodies that govern air travel are headquartered at nearby Montreal – the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO), Inter-national Air Travel Association (IATA) and the Airports Council International (ACI).

Much has happened since its publication, but the principles of border crossing and security, essentially remain the same.

A human mixing pot

Not only in scale, but also in opportunity of great architecture and commerce for example, the airport is a true twenty-first century icon. But alongside are the vulnerabilities of post-cold-war politics and terrorism. In a world that fluctuates between borderless globalisation and claustrophobic xenophobia, the airport has to be many things for its different users, all at the same time.

It brings together at a single location both, the ideas and the reality of security, territory and population. It also brings together a complex web of local, national and international laws, as well as surveillance for conflicting reasons – on behalf of companies, governments and individuals. It connects many social spheres and has to provide incarceration amidst an illusion of infinite freedom. As political scientists state, thus the airport is both – the definition of an immense problem as well as a statement of its grand solution.

Who and what are you

By the end of this decade, seven billion people are expected to pass through airports travelling nationally and internationally, consisting of about half a billion passport holders. There is already the pressure for the élite to be treated with queue-less instant service. Archaic instruments such as visas cause additional bottlenecks on an already overstretched service infrastructure.

Many of the sixty-five million internationally displaced persons also arrive at international airports, some of them seeking asylum and in the most complex legal situations, in conditions of statelessness. There are women and children requiring immediate humanitarian attention.

Amidst all this, are individuals attempting to travel on one of the over 60 million stolen or lost travel documents, individuals suspected of commercial crime, smuggling and drugs, and those with a criminal background and intent. Finally, there are the dreaded terrorists, detecting and stopping whom could prevent untold loss and tragedy. These could arrive disguised across the entire spectrum – from the élite to the asylum seeker. There is no way to tell what persona they will don next.

The freedom of restriction

Apart from ICAO, IATA and the ACI a number of other regional and national bodies formulate guiding principles for all this. In the US, it is the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) as well as the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

Involving almost the entire community of nations, the governance environment is a combination of international treaties, national laws, local by-laws as well as management practices. The ICAO itself goes back to the Chicago Convention of 1944 (ratified in 1947) as well as its various annexures and amendments.

In a broad sense, airports have the objective to maximise national security. However, prevalent business models also require them to maximise commerce. This leads to the complex layouts and the alternating of wide-open spaces with narrow passages and barriers. Overall, it has been a question of optimising space, speed and security.

For the security aspect, initially it was considered a question of minimising the time to process. Today, the focus is on the outcome. Also in recent years, there has been a need to re-evaluate the security objective function itself, because the dependence of returns on investment in this field is difficult to quantify.

In general, security is said to depend on ID documents, identification and detection devices, CCTV and data such as no-fly lists. Viewed individually, each have well-understood shortcomings, however together, do provide a system that seems to hold. Added to this in recent years have been strategies of risk management, more comprehensive post-event assessment, and somewhat controversially, using databases as an instrument of selection, separation and exclusion.

In principle, these violate privacy and personal data protection laws. However, many agencies espouse temporary profiles bringing together data for the eyes of experts, while maintaining the essential separation in the machine form, as a bare minimum, looking at today’s threats.

Ideally, passports serve well for external movement. However, the use of ID cards for internal movement opens up many issues of acceptability, standards and authentication. Similarly, despite constant advancements, both in the technology and practice, biometrics as valves that control global flows of humanity, could be restricted only to international border crossing.

Imponderables invariably turn up, such as what happens to your data across borders. For example, the moment it reaches the United States, is it subject to the USA-PATRIOT Act? Few of us remember that this ten-letter abbreviation stands for: Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism, as signed by President George W. Bush on October 26, 2001. This has subsequently been extended and amended in 2011 and 2015 under the Obama administration, and is now known, quite ironically, as the Freedom Act.

A Difference Machine

For the airport then, the notion put forward underlying its laws, regulations, procedures and technologies, is to facilitate global mobility and at the same time, if required, fortress countries and continents. Smart borders has been a euphemism for the increasing use of biometrics (face and fingerprints mainly) in this context.

Peter Adey is one of the contributors in Mark Salter’s book and his paper – Mobilities and Modulations: The Airport as a Difference Machine – is a powerful one and immediately caught the imagination, not only of those wanting to tame the unwieldy airport beast, but also of businesses looking to maximise profits within. In sociological terms, he described this continuous and unending process of segregation being based on securitising identity and identification, with political asylum at one end to credit card theft at the other. At an airport, this synchronises well with the twin ideas of maximising security and commerce. In addition, both have established paradigms of profiling, though with different objectives. However, the underlying commonality of securitised identity provides a significant intersection.

Already, the mobile phone and the use of biometrics to authenticate payments provides even greater common ground, between the authority of one and the power of the other, in its capacity to organise the identification of individuals. Newer ID schemes have already breached the conventional distinction between the government and the commercial, domestic and international and the inside and the outside.

However, experts reckon that despite techniques being available, they have not been put together in the most effective way – for the identification, classification and managing of individuals and groups sorted by a level of dangerousness, so to say.

Behaviour and identity observation

Three specific areas have immediate potential. Biographic search is one of them that helps investigators look beyond singular physical identification characteristics. The biometric silos also need to be turned upside down and provided with connecting passageways. Thus names, locations, faces and other specifics can be looked at more holistically and intuitively like a human mind does.

Lastly, there is the hypothesis that identity itself is not the final frontier of security. It is the knowing that there is intent. One of the important ways that an airport functions are segregating the streams among the frequent-flying ‘kinetic élite’ (as termed by Rem Koolhaas), the more general classes, the refugees and vagabond immigrants (some needing deportation) and finally those that need a closer look for security reasons. It is not only being able to foil their passage at arrival or departure, but also keep the airport itself out of reach from being a target.

Thus there is the current debate between behaviour-based and identity-based techniques. Objections abound, and these too need to be addressed, especially those in the realm of privacy, protection, due process, discrimination, international law and conventions.

Already businesses, airlines and governments are imposing visible and invisible levies that support all means of security at the airport. With the annual traffic projected to touch seven billion passengers via thirty-five million flights in one hundred and ninety-one countries, the nine thousand odd airports where they originate and land, assume more importance than ever before.

Not one of them is known as Checkpoint Delta, but I thought to use the name to remind us of what changes and what remains the same.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Smarter security for safer estate living
neaMetrics Suprema Integrated Solutions Surveillance Access Control & Identity Management Residential Estate (Industry)
The expansion of residential estates has led to many communities being constructed with security as an afterthought. Unfortunately, fencing, cameras, and a guard at the gate only create a false sense of safety, which vanishes after the first incident.

Read more...
Making drone security more accessible
Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry) AI & Data Analytics IoT & Automation
Michael Lever discusses advances in drone technology, focusing on cost reductions and the implementation of automated services, including beyond line of sight capabilities, for residential estates with SMART Security Solutions.

Read more...
Private fire services becoming the norm?
Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Editor's Choice
As the infrastructure and service delivery in many of South Africa’s major cities decline, with a few, limited exceptions, more of the work that should be done by the state has fallen to private companies.

Read more...
View from the trenches
Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Security Services & Risk Management Residential Estate (Industry)
There are many great options available to estates for effectively managing their security and operations, but those in the trenches are often limited by body corporate/HOA budget restrictions and misunderstandings.

Read more...
SMART Estate Security Conference KZN 2025
Arteco Global Africa OneSpace Technologies SMART Security Solutions Technews Publishing Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Security Services & Risk Management Residential Estate (Industry)
May 2025 saw the SMART Security Solutions team heading off to Durban for our annual Estate Security Conference, once again hosted at the Mount Edgecombe Country Club.

Read more...
Identity, Security & Access Alliance focuses on intelligence and integration
SMART Security Solutions Ideco Biometrics BoomGate Systems Bosch Building Technologies Technews Publishing Integrated Solutions Surveillance Access Control & Identity Management
The Identity, Security & Access Alliance (ISAA) hosted several launch events in Johannesburg in August, showcasing the participating companies’ technical solutions with a primary focus on the solutions made possible by integrating high-quality systems to deliver comprehensive solutions.

Read more...
Get the AI fundamentals right
Leaderware Editor's Choice Surveillance AI & Data Analytics
Much of the marketing for CCTV AI detection implies the client can just drop the AI into their existing systems and operations, and they will be detecting all criminals and be far more efficient when doing it.

Read more...
SMART Surveillance Conference in Johannesburg
Arteco Global Africa Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Axis Communications SA neaMetrics Editor's Choice Surveillance Security Services & Risk Management Logistics (Industry) AI & Data Analytics
SMART Security Solutions hosted its annual SMART Surveillance Conference in Johannesburg in July, welcoming several guests, sponsors, and speakers for an informative and enjoyable day examining the evolution of the surveillance market.

Read more...
Rethinking access control in high-risk logistics environments
ATG Digital Access Control & Identity Management Transport (Industry) Logistics (Industry) Facilities & Building Management
South Africa’s logistics sector is under constant pressure, not only from external threats like hijackings and cargo theft, but also from internal vulnerabilities, operational blind spots, and limited support.

Read more...
Why DIY IoT does not scale
IoT & Automation Transport (Industry) Logistics (Industry)
From fleet management to inventory management, and security monitoring to equipment maintenance, the Internet of Things (IoT) has become an integral part of business operations in almost every sector today.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.