Fibre optic legal tips

Residential Estate Security Handbook 2016 - Vol 2 Editor's Choice, Security Services & Risk Management, Residential Estate (Industry)

South Africa is far behind developed countries when it comes to electronic communications. Back in 2008, the Department of Communications published draft guidelines for the rapid deployment of electronic communications facilities to make it easier for electronic communications networks to be established in South Africa, but these guidelines are yet to be finalised and implemented.

Claire Cowan, Shepstone & Wylie.
Claire Cowan, Shepstone & Wylie.

This does not seem to be hindering network infrastructure providers who are popping up everywhere, eager to install fibre optic communications networks in residential estates all over South Africa.

A fibre optic communications network commences with the physical installation of fibre optic cables and associated infrastructure by a network provider. Once the physical network is in place, it is made available to Internet service providers (ISPs) who use the network to provide Internet, HDTV, telephony and other services to subscribers who are connected to that network.

To secure the installation of a fibre optic network within an estate, the body corporate or homeowners’ association (HOA) must engage in negotiations, and ultimately conclude an agreement, with the network provider. Body corporates and HOAs are often unaware of important issues which should be included in that agreement. The following are a few things to bear in mind.


A network provider has to hold an electronic communications network service or 'ECNS' licence issued by the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa (ICASA), which permits it to install and operate a fibre optic network in your estate.

ICASA is a public body established by government to regulate the electronic communications sector in South Africa. Amongst other things, it issues licences and sets the minimum operating standards with which service providers must comply.

You must ensure that the network provider warrants that it is appropriately licensed by ICASA to install and operate the network in your estate, and that it will remain so licensed for the duration of the agreement. Licences are not that difficult to obtain, so it is also important to make sure that the network provider is reputable and not a fly-by-night. Ask for references.


To secure a return on their investment, most network providers will request that the agreement endures for a minimum period of time, particularly if the network has been installed free of charge. This is a reasonable request provided that the minimum period of time is not too long and that if the network fails to operate to your satisfaction, you can terminate the agreement before the minimum period has expired.

The type of network

Not all networks are created equal. A network in an office block may require different capacity to a network in a residential estate. You must understand the type of network that is being installed and whether it has the capacity to be used for your intended purposes.

Your network provider should be sufficiently knowledgeable to advise you on the different networks that are available in the market and those which are suitable for your intended purposes. To avoid a dispute (and disappointment) at a later stage, make sure that before you begin, your network provider understands who will be using the network and what it will be used for, so that it can make an appropriate recommendation.

Your agreement should include an installation plan clearly setting out the manner in which the network will be installed (including deadlines) and at whose expense. Do not leave it up to the network provider to determine where and when the network will be installed.

Network capacity

The speed at which users are able to transmit and receive data via a fibre optic network varies depending on a number of factors, including the type of network, where the user is situated on the network and how many people are accessing the network simultaneously. Furthermore, the user selects its network speed in the package deal it concludes with the ISP.

The body corporate or HOA must make sure that the network has the capacity to support the number of users who may connect to it at any one time, and the services for which it may be used. The required capacity must be included in the agreement and the network provider must undertake to ensure that the network operates at that capacity at all times regardless of the abovementioned factors.

Include a clause in your agreement entitling you to cancel it if the network repeatedly fails to operate at the agreed capacity, as you do not want to be stuck until the end of the period of the agreement with a network that is insufficient for your requirements.

The End User and Subscriber Service Charter Regulations issued by ICASA do set out minimum standards to be achieved by ECNS licence holders in relation to availability, connectivity and so on, but you may want to include your own.

Is the network open or closed?

Some network providers attempt to limit access to the network to certain listed ISPs with whom they may have arrangements. This means that the residents in an estate may not be able to use their preferred ISP if it is not on the network provider’s list. In terms of the Code of Conduct issued by ICASA during 2007, end users should be given a right to an ISP of their choice.

Excluding an ISP from accessing the network is also contrary to the Electronic Communications Act, 2005, which specifically provides that every ECNS licensee must on request, provide an ISP with access to a network, unless the request is unreasonable. According to ICASA, a request is not unreasonable if it is technologically and economically feasible and the network will be used more efficiently.

So make sure that you are able to use the ISPs of your choice over the network, or if the network is nevertheless closed, it is opened to all ISPs after a short time period. Remember that the more ISPs that use the network, the more competitive their pricing and the more innovative their service offerings.

It is very common for a network provider to itself act as an ISP and offer Internet and other services via its own network. To do this, in addition to its ECNS licence, the network provider must hold an electronic communications service or ‘ECS’ licence issued by ICASA.

Safety issues

Before the network provider is given access to commence installing the network in your estate, make sure that they have committed to the following critical issues in the agreement:

• At all times to comply with all laws, including those dealing with the conditions of work of its employees and subcontractors, the safety of the work performed and the health and safety of all persons on the estate where the work is being performed.

• To maintain sufficient public liability and other insurance cover in respect of the risks it undertakes in terms of the agreement.

• To only use components that meet prescribed safety standards.

• To indemnify the body corporate or HOA against any claims for loss, damages, costs and other expenses suffered by any third party as a result of the negligent or intentional and unlawful acts or omissions of the network provider or those of its employees and subcontractors.

Ownership and maintenance

Ownership of the network is generally agreed with the network provider, but may also be determined by the residential ownership structure within the estate.

Generally speaking, the network provider owns that part of the network comprising the equipment which receives communication signals for distribution within the estate, the HOA owns all cabling and associated components traversing common property, and the sectional or land owners own their residential connections to the network, including the modem, telephone, television and other device to which the electronic signal is ultimately delivered.

Ownership is important to distinguish, since unless the parties agree to the contrary, each owner must at its cost, maintain the portion of the network which it owns. Fortunately, fibre optic cabling, in general, does not require much maintenance and most problems occur due to external interference.

If it so happens that the network provider agrees to maintain the network for you, make sure the scope of the maintenance is specified in the agreement, together with the monthly maintenance fee, any escalations in such fee and whether the fee includes labour and/or spare parts.

No warranties

Don’t be tempted to give the network provider any warranties regarding the number of residents who will sign up for fibre. If the service is what it should be, there should be no shortage of subscribers.

For more information contact Claire Cowan, +27 (0) 31 575 7000,

Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Axis gives a brighter future for children
Issue 1 2020, Axis Communications SA , Editor's Choice
Fully networked camera solution provides visibility and accountability, letting orphanage focus on what’s important – its children.

SFP Security & Fire becomes ISF SFP
Issue 1 2020, ISF SFP , Editor's Choice
SFP Security & Fire was sold to ISF in 2019, becoming ISF SFP and attaining Level-1 BEE status.

Janu-worry or Twenty-Plenty?
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
If the available security spend right now is somewhere between limited and non-existent, here are just a few suggestions.

CCTV surveillance needs are critical in defining types of camera deployment
Issue 1 2020, Leaderware , Editor's Choice
Cameras by themselves do not reduce crime; they need to be implemented as part of a considered strategy of crime prevention and detection.

Trends 2020
Issue 1 2020, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked a few people from diverse companies to join us in a round-table discussion about what they expect to see happening in their environments in the coming year.

Seven key trends for 2020
Issue 1 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Editor's Choice
Hikvision looks at a few trends that will affect the security industry in 2020 and beyond.

Hundreds of millions to reskill
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
By 2022 alone, 75 million jobs will probably be displaced across 20 major economies, while 133 million new ones will spring up in industries that are only just gaining traction.

Slow and steady wins the access race
Issue 1 2020, ZKTeco, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice, Commercial (Industry)
The commercial sector is slow in migrating to new access control technologies, with the majority of companies remaining with card and fingerprint solutions.

Client property access integrity
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
Blind or unquestioned trust is something that we all seem to willingly and unconditionally give our security service providers and their reaction officers.

From physical security to cybersecurity
Access & Identity Management Handbook 2020, Genetec , Cyber Security, Security Services & Risk Management
Genetec discusses the security-of-security concept as a means to protect cameras, door controllers and other physical security devices and systems against cybercriminal activity.