The current approach to securing estates

Residential Estate Security Handbook 2016 - Vol 2 Editor's Choice, Security Services & Risk Management

Security on residential estates has changed substantially from the first estates to what we see being built today. The motivation has been increased demands by residents for better security in an increasing crime environment as well as massive changes in technology.

So, the question that needs to be answered is, what should you expect to find as a security solution on today’s estates?

The answer is that estates are using the knowledge of the last few years and doing what is starting to become an industry standard. There are also estates that are either cash strapped or have not felt the impact of crime. They are making very little change and relying mostly on a manpower solution. When you visit these low crime estates, it is a surprise to find that there are still places in the country that the crime wave has left alone. May they last for a long time.

Let’s define what the ‘crime advanced’ estates are doing:


We start with manpower. Estates, if large enough, are employing their own security managers. These managers are being forced to operate as real managers with formal security plans, budgets, cost reports and doing additional studies to improve their skills. They are measured on performance and are results driven.

There is clearly a shortage of such individuals, and there seems to be good opportunities for suitably motivated individuals, to work in this field.

The manpower on the ground has also seen his/her job become the ‘door man’ who greets everybody and solves problems. They need to be aware of the unusual and act to reduce risk. Even the patrol and response guard cannot be the man in military uniform, charging around and looking dangerous. As I was told by one of the players in the industry, the guarding has to portray ‘understated elegance’. This has become a specialist part of the guarding industry.


We still see walls being built as barriers, although most experts agree that the best choice is a mesh fence that allows for high levels of visibility (natural surveillance). These fences are a minimum of 2,4 m high with an overhang to make entry difficult.

With the move towards thermal cameras on the perimeter, the more open the mesh the better. Walls and tight mesh fences are a complete barrier to thermal cameras. There is a need for under dig devices and, as a minimum, electrified overhangs.

If the perimeter is further protected by thermal cameras, then the fence is just a delay mechanism. You will have the evidence that there is an attempted break-in and respond. As long as the perimeter solution keeps the criminal there to be focus on it, all is well.

The thermal cameras used as alarms, and alarm verification are to be found on an increasing number of estates. This is a costly experience with very good returns in quality of security. When funding is a problem, we still find optical cameras with infrared lighting do a good job. Although the results are not as good as the thermal solution.

That brings us to the control room, which should be within the estate and not on the boundary.

Control room

Control rooms are increasingly becoming an asset on estates. They are able to respond to thermal camera alarms, electric fence alarms and act as a call centre for the estate. A well-constructed and operated control room adds a lot of value to the estate. With this in place, a greater level of asset management is possible. Alarms from equipment, storage areas and even homes can be monitored. This then becomes the centre of knowledge on the estate.

Access control

The next component: access control. The move from RFID to biometric is common. This has resulted in fairly big access control upgrades and an increasing acceptance of biometric control. The improvement of equipment over the past few years has resulted in fewer fingerprints not being suitable. This is really a good example of a technology finally maturing. In most cases, the residents and their visitors are controlled in vehicles and all other entrants are managed as individuals. Turnstiles are commonly used to control the individuals, either at the main entrance or at dedicated contractors’ entrances.

The access control system is then used to ensure that all contractors are off the estate at the end of the day, as well as in incident management and investigations.

The access control areas are all well covered with cameras with the overview camera becoming popular. This provides an overview of an incident as evidence. There is also an increasing trend to have body worn cameras on all staff at the entrances. This provides visual and audio evidence of incidents.

Visitor management

The control of visitors is the next item. There is a flood of visitor management systems available that allow the estates to manage this group. Most of them integrate with the access control system and provide a platform for managing the group. With a large number of crimes being committed by criminals that came through the front gate, access control is most important. The process should be robust.

It is important to bring all this information and incidents together in one place for effective management. This is usually done with an electronic occurrence book software package. The system makes it easier to manage the security on the estate and often plays a positive role in facility management as well.

Reporting an intelligence

This leaves the need for good reporting systems that allows the management to be aware of the status of all the systems at all times. Well constructed management reporting can be a first indication of problems in the operation. The reporting should include regular audits and testing of all the systems to confirm compliance and develop better solutions.

As a support to the overall security, the installation of good alternative power supplies and surge arrestors are vital. The quality of power supplies, particularly along the perimeter is vital to the performance of the system.

And then, finally, the security network and the need to keep it secure. This is the one area that still requires some work. It is just too easy to put the security and business systems on one network. If there was a way to provide the correct level of security, then this would be a winner. Sadly, this is not always so. Many of the really good security systems are vulnerable through the network. It is likely that we will start to see some improvement in this area. The sooner the better.


Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page

Further reading:

Axis gives a brighter future for children
Issue 1 2020, Axis Communications SA , Editor's Choice
Fully networked camera solution provides visibility and accountability, letting orphanage focus on what’s important – its children.

SFP Security & Fire becomes ISF SFP
Issue 1 2020, ISF SFP , Editor's Choice
SFP Security & Fire was sold to ISF in 2019, becoming ISF SFP and attaining Level-1 BEE status.

Janu-worry or Twenty-Plenty?
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
If the available security spend right now is somewhere between limited and non-existent, here are just a few suggestions.

CCTV surveillance needs are critical in defining types of camera deployment
Issue 1 2020, Leaderware , Editor's Choice
Cameras by themselves do not reduce crime; they need to be implemented as part of a considered strategy of crime prevention and detection.

Trends 2020
Issue 1 2020, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked a few people from diverse companies to join us in a round-table discussion about what they expect to see happening in their environments in the coming year.

Seven key trends for 2020
Issue 1 2020, Hikvision South Africa , Editor's Choice
Hikvision looks at a few trends that will affect the security industry in 2020 and beyond.

Hundreds of millions to reskill
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
By 2022 alone, 75 million jobs will probably be displaced across 20 major economies, while 133 million new ones will spring up in industries that are only just gaining traction.

Slow and steady wins the access race
Issue 1 2020, ZKTeco, Technews Publishing , Editor's Choice, Commercial (Industry)
The commercial sector is slow in migrating to new access control technologies, with the majority of companies remaining with card and fingerprint solutions.

Client property access integrity
Issue 1 2020 , Editor's Choice
Blind or unquestioned trust is something that we all seem to willingly and unconditionally give our security service providers and their reaction officers.

From physical security to cybersecurity
Access & Identity Management Handbook 2020, Genetec , Cyber Security, Security Services & Risk Management
Genetec discusses the security-of-security concept as a means to protect cameras, door controllers and other physical security devices and systems against cybercriminal activity.