Analogue fights back

May 2016 CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring

Just as we were all prepared to announce the death of analogue and the ultimate victory of network (or IP) surveillance, the analogue industry jumped back into the game, offering HD (high definition) video and more from analogue systems. And even more importantly, you can use them on your existing analogue infrastructure – so they say.

According to the companies involved, depending on which version one chooses, HD analogue can deliver higher definition video over the same infrastructure – with a few changes – but still keeping it analogue with no latency and at a lower cost. This makes it easier to manage and install as the technical trickery of IP systems is avoided. In many installations, especially smaller ones, HD analogue systems are not only retaining existing clients, but gaining new converts who would otherwise have gone the IP route.

However, it’s not a simple decision to stay with analogue. There are various HD standards in the analogue world and each want to be the eventual winner. Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked three of the leading players to tell us about their HD offerings in the analogue world, what their standard offers customers and how they see it developing in future.

Rebooting analogue

Frank Zhang, product manager for Hikvision’s backend devices explains that the Chinese surveillance giant provides its Turbo HD products built on the HDTVI standard. “Compared with other HD analogue standards, HDTVI excels in ultra-high signal bandwidth, which results in more saturated colour and brightness, and makes the images more clear. Hikvision will soon introduce an upgraded Turbo HD solution (Turbo HD 3.0), with product models providing up to 5 MP resolution (2592x1944).”

Another Chinese company steaming ahead in the surveillance world is Dahua. It has developed the HDCVI standard. According to the company’s John Li, compared to other HD analogue standard, HDCVI is better, firstly because it owns independent intellectual property rights.

Secondly, Li says HDCVI has full compatibility with legacy and other systems. This means HDCVI is ‘penta-brid’, which means it is compatible with HDCVI / AHD / TVI / IP / CVBS. The whole HDCVI family is also compatible with both older and new versions of its products.

In addition, Li says HDCVI features higher resolution and longer transmission distances, and not only provides 720p and 1080p resolutions, but 4 megapixel and 4K (8 megapixel) as well. As for the transmission distance, HDCVI supports up to 1200 m over coaxial cable and 450 m over UTP.

The company also boasts that HDCVI supports multi-signal transmission in one coaxial cable. In other words: video, audio, data and power.

It’s worth noting that Zhang says the Turbo HD solution offers seamless compatibility with various third-party HDTVI compliant cameras and DVRs. Turbo HD 3.0 will also support AHD compliant products.

The third standard to consider is AHD (analogue high definition). Developed by Nextchip, it is promoted in South Africa by Hitek Security. Tomer Elhadad, CEO of Hitek, says AHD offers a few advantages of its own. The first is that these cameras support both old analogue technology as well as AHD. Moreover, the AHD DVR from Hitek supports analogue, AHD as well as IP.

Elhadad adds that customers can develop AHD systems using AHD devices from the Provision range, which Hitek sells, or any other brand. This is the same as people were used to with traditional analogue systems. Unlike other standards, you are not limited to buying all your product from the same manufacturer.

In terms of resolution, AHD already supports up to 2 MP, with 3 MP and 4 MP solutions in the pipeline.

Something old, something new

One of the alleged benefits of HD analogue systems is that users can make use of their existing infrastructure, which means you save on cabling. Elhadad says upgrading to AHD is as simple as changing cameras and DVR units, ‘and you set to go’.

Hikvision is the same. Zhang explains that customers only need to replace the front-end cameras and backend DVRs, again without the trouble of re-cabling. What’s more, the Hikvision Turbo HD 3.0 supports up to 1 200 m transmission distances.

Dahua, again, echoes the others. Customers can seamlessly upgrade from SD analogue to an HDCVI system, the only thing they need to do is to replace the analogue cameras and DVRs with HDCVI versions. No cabling needs to be changed.

According to Li, HDCVI has more than 10 million supporters from 150 countries, and over 200 global partners have joined the Dahua HDCVI Academy, aiming to accelerate HD development. The company believes that, although the current HD analogue market is shared by CVI, AHD and TVI, it is an inevitable trend that all standards will converge, as convergence is a real and important customer requirement.

However, Elhadad says last year’s export figures from China show that AHD is leading the pack by a significant margin when it comes to analogue HD sales.

Analytics on analogue

In today’s IP surveillance world, one of the benefits of higher resolution images is the ability to add value to the installation with video analytics. Fortunately, the same is possible with HD analogue.

Dahua provides video management software, the Smart PSS for PCs and DMSS for mobile devices that support analytics. HDCVI technology supports various intelligent functions including motion detection, tripwires, left object detection, facial recognition, people counting, heat maps etc.

Elhadad adds that any video analytic software already available in the market will be able to make use of AHD video footage. Hitek also offers CMS software that allows you to manage all your Provision ISR devices under one platform.

Hikvision provides its own video management software with Turbo HD analogue solutions. This includes the current iVMS-4200 VMS and iVMS-5200 Professional VMS. Video analytics is available on these platforms, including motion detection, intrusion detection, line-crossing detection, alarm management video quality detection and more smart features.

The bottom line

We naturally expect the vendors to promote their own products and promise awesome results for those who implement them, but when dealing with HD analogue, what are the real cost advantages a company would experience? After all, when buying new cameras and DVRs, you are committing significant funds to the project.

Zhang explains that the advantages of HD analogue over IP systems are mainly in cost-savings and their real-time capability (non-latency transmission). In terms of upgrading from SD analogue to HD analogue, users will benefit from:

• No need for re-cabling, which reduces installation costs,

• HD analogue devices are more cost-effective, and

• More flexible in restructuring, you don’t have to do all the restructuring at one time.

In terms of the installation of new HD analogue systems, users will benefit from:

• HD analogue devices are more cost-effective and costs less to install,

• Easy to install, easy to use,

• Low demands on the installer’s technical skills,

• Low maintenance cost, and

• No need for switches or hubs for bridging, which also reduces the overall costs.

When comparing the cost to an IP solution, Elhadad says, “I can say that the cost of AHD is similar to standard analogue systems and an IP system will still be in the range of two or three times more expensive.”

Li says that even if a customer has an SD analogue system, simply replacing all the cabling costs a lot. For most mid-sized or large surveillance systems, such as buildings or public facilities, it is unrealistic to change the cabling. Furthermore, the cameras and HCVRs in an HDCVI system are “remarkably less expensive” than IP cameras and NVRs of similar performance.

From the above, it seems clear that analogue is fighting back, not only to retain its market share, but to grow it with the introduction of HD solutions that can compete with most of the IP systems being installed today. Over time, it is probably a good bet that the competition between CVI, TVI and AHD will see the manufacturers releasing higher definition capabilities and longer transmission lengths to support their zero-latency systems. Who will win in the end remains to be seen, but it seems as if customers can once again include analogue in their long-term plans.

For more information, contact Dahua, +86-571-87688883, overseas@dahuatech.com, www.dahuasecurity.com; Hikvision South Africa, +27 (0)10 035 1172, support.africa@hikvision.com, www.hikvision.com; HiTek Security Distributors, +27 (0)21 946 3344, sales@hiteksecurity.net, www.hiteksecurity.net

4K analogue video

Analogue CCTV users can now enjoy 5 MP HDTVI and 4K video resolution while safeguarding their investment with existing cabling infrastructure. Hikvision is launching its third-generation analogue HD solution, Turbo HD 3.0, which also supports latency-free 1080p HD video up to 800m and 720p transmission up to 1 200 m over coaxial cable.

Turbo HD 3.0 uses HDTVI technology, eliminating compatibility issues whenever you have to mix old technology with new products, and making installation simple and cost-effective.

Hikvision’s high-calibre H.264+ compression technology improves encoding efficiency by up to 50% compared to standard H.264, dramatically reducing bitrates while maintaining high transmission quality without losing forensic details.

Hikvision’s Power-over-Coax (PoC) feature simplifies installation, as one coaxial cable carries both the video signal and the power supply. This translates to reduced installation time, which also translates to a reduction in both installation and material costs. In addition, the Turbo HD 3.0 analogue solution supports UTC for remote set-up and configuration and enables control of the OSD menu and PTZ control via coaxial cable, enabling faster camera installation and easier management.

Turbo HD 3.0 is also compatible with the majority of products from other manufacturers.

For more information contact Hikvision, +86-571-8700-6060, wulin@hikvision.com, www.hikvision.com


Credit(s)






Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Why rehearsals and drills for crises and evacuation are so important
August 2019, Leaderware , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Security Services & Risk Management
The rehearsal of concept (ROC) drill has been used extensively in the military, but is just as important when facing risks in organisations and institutions to protect people on the ground.

Read more...
Milestone partners prove their skills
August 2019, Milestone Systems , News, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Training & Education
Within the span of one week in mid-May, the Milestone Learning & Performance group celebrated important benchmarks: 200 000 course registrations and tutorial views, and 10 000 certifications.

Read more...
ONVIF Hosts 20th Developers’ Plugfest
August 2019 , News, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
ONVIF, the global standardisation initiative for IP-based physical security products, hosted its twentieth ONVIF Developers’ Plugfest in early June in Tokyo.

Read more...
Licence plate recognition camera
August 2019 , Products, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
VIVOTEK has introduced a new licence plate recognition camera featuring built-in licence plate recognition software and edge-computing capability.

Read more...
Securing Savannah Hills Estate
August 2019, Rhyco Risk Projects , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Savannah Hills Estate in Midrand planned a security upgrade which was awarded to Rhyco Risk Projects. The project started in March 2019 and was completed in May 2019.

Read more...
10 things to consider when shopping for a VMS
August 2019, Genetec , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Integrated Solutions
Today’s video management systems (VMS) provide a wide range of tools and capabilities that help make security personnel more efficient by allowing them to focus on what really matters.

Read more...
How far are we really at with artificial intelligence?
August 2019, Axis Communications SA , Editor's Choice, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, IT infrastructure, Residential Estate (Industry)
Justin Ludik unpacks exactly how far AI has come and what it potentially can do for society and more importantly, surveillance.

Read more...
Enhancing security with AI
August 2019, Hikvision South Africa , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring
Hikvision explains how residential estates can revolutionise their security strategies and outcomes with artificial intelligence.

Read more...
More than simply a camera
August 2019, Forbatt SA, Secutel Technologies , CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Residential Estate (Industry)
With the human element being the weakest link in all security solutions, Hi-Tech Security Solutions looks at the pros and cons of using body-worn cameras in estates.

Read more...
The importance of effective perimeter security
August 2019, Elf Rentals - Electronic Security Solutions, Stafix , Editor's Choice, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Residential Estate (Industry)
Protecting the perimeter is critical for any residential estate; how does one go about making sure your perimeter is as secure as possible?

Read more...