Health & Safety vs Security Risk Assessment II
October 2015, Security Services & Risk Management
By Dianne Ayres, Alwinco.
Company X has items of extreme value that the shareholders desperately want to protect and thus it is decided that a security risk assessment should be conducted on the premises. The local security company is contacted and their best salesman is sent out to assess the company.
This assessor inspects the safe room where these valuable items are stored. “In my opinion, both the door and the walls are impenetrable. No one can get in so your items are safe. This is definitely a low risk area. A rating of ‘1’. No worries,” he says. “Now, what I would recommend is that we go back to the previous area as I have some products here that will work ....”
The company followed the salesman’s advice and purchased several expensive hardware items that were installed throughout the property, but the safe room remained as is. Not even a month later, thieves came in through the roof and stole all the valuables that were in this specific safe room. The shareholders called in an independent to review and reassess their security.
Many assessors make use of a grading system to determine risk. Unfortunately this method is a direct overflow from Health & Safety and is inaccurate as risk cannot be defined in terms of probability ranging from a 1 (little to no risk) to a 5 (extreme high risk). Risk needs to be viewed in regards to the opportunity present for a crime to be committed and not as an opinion in light of probability.
After a lengthy online debate, the owner of company Y challenged the independent to prove risk in terms of opportunity. He had recently had his premises evaluated on the grading system. The perimeter fence was rated as a low as they had recently mounted an electrical fence along the top. The highest score, therefore the area with the most risk, was allocated to the gate. Guards were stationed there 24/7 to remedy this as the salesman-assessor had advised.
The independent accepted the challenge. “Sure,” he stated. “Let me show you how an opportunity for a crime can be created.” Company Y supplied the independent with a fancy looking laptop, which although it looked good on the outside, it no longer worked. The independent placed this laptop inside of the property behind the low-ranking fence so that it was visible from the street.
Much to the owner’s surprise, the next morning the laptop was gone. The opportunistic thief had managed to climb over the fence and take the laptop during the night, despite the fact that there were guards posted around the corner at the gate.
The problem with the grading system is that it essentially remains a matter of opinion. I am short, unfit and have a fear of heights so I would not see myself scaling a 2 m high wall, as an example. This implies I would rate this wall as a low-risk, but to a desperate criminal, this very same wall will not present such a big obstacle and if he is determined, he will get over it. Remember that the criminal has a completely different mindset and this is why it is necessary to think out of the box and view security risk in terms of opportunity and not what you or I, or even the salesman, may deem as probable. For more information contact Alwinco, +27 (0)71 319 4735, dianne@alwinco.co.za, www.alwinco.co.za
|
|
|
|
|
|
Further reading:
- Significant differences in perceptions on state of digital trust
November 2018, CA Southern Africa, Access Control & Identity Management, Security Services & Risk Management
Nearly half of businesses admit to selling customer data, despite claiming data protection as paramount; consumer behaviour shows strong correlation between loss of business and lack of digital trust.
- Reliability a fundamental in visitor management
November 2018, Powell Tronics, Access Control & Identity Management, Integrated Solutions, Security Services & Risk Management
With the rapid evolution of biometric technology, there are many options available in the marketplace that promise varying levels of performance.
- Optimal selection of CCTV operators
November 2018, Leaderware, This Week's Editor's Pick, CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Security Services & Risk Management
Technology is often seen as the primary factor in the success of CCTV surveillance control rooms, yet Dr Craig Donald has seen new control rooms with the most up-to-date technology fail.
- The latest X-ray scanning solutions
November 2018, Technews Publishing, Asset Management, EAS, RFID, Security Services & Risk Management
Hi-Tech Security Solutions asked three suppliers of X-ray scanning equipment for some insights into the latest products and their safety.
- Managing business continuity and disaster recovery
November 2018, Technews Publishing, IT infrastructure, Security Services & Risk Management
Organisations are increasingly reliant on their IT systems and data, but they are faced with risks in the form of anything from accidental data loss, to deliberate acts of sabotage.
- Velocity Audit
November 2018, Excellerate Services , Security Services & Risk Management
Excellerate Services has adopted an outcome-based service model which is underpinned by a Customer Experience (CXM) and SLA Management platform called Velocity Audit.
- Smart cities spend less
November 2018, Axis Communications SA, Government and Parastatal (Industry), CCTV, Surveillance & Remote Monitoring, Security Services & Risk Management
A proactive management model allows cities to work smarter and save money while offering better services and results to their citizens.
- What about the service level agreement?
November 2018, Vision Catcher, This Week's Editor's Pick, Security Services & Risk Management
Niall Beazley discusses the importance of a reliable service level agreement (SLA) if you want to rest assured in the long-term efficacy of your security installation.
- The need for resilience in national infrastructure
November 2018, Government and Parastatal (Industry), Cyber Security, Security Services & Risk Management
The industries and infrastructure on which so much of our daily lives depend are deep in the midst of mass digitisation.
- Smart home security services
November 2018, Fidelity Security Group, Security Services & Risk Management, Products
SecureHome enables you to view the status of your home security, quickly arm or disarm your alarm system, and receive alerts using your smartphone.
- Smart city spending to soar
November 2018, Integrated Solutions, Security Services & Risk Management
IDC forecasts annual technology spending by Middle East and Africa smart cities to total $2.7 billion by 2022, with Dubai and Riyadh leading the way.
- Powering the Internet of Everything
November 2018, Pinnacle Instruments SA, Integrated Solutions, Security Services & Risk Management
Cities around the world have set their digital transformation sights on uplifting healthcare, education and delivering quality utility and transport services while also prioritising public safety.
|
|
