Second chance or folly?

July 2015 Security Services & Risk Management

Another stark reminder of how seriously our justice system takes qualifications fraud presented itself earlier this month when former police spokesperson, Vincent Mdunge was sentenced to five years imprisonment by the Durban Regional Court.

Mdunge was caught red-handed last year on two counts of fraud and one of forgery when he presented a fake matric certificate in order to further his studies at UNISA and gain promotion in the police. While the judge acknowledged that he was a first time offender, she still threw the proverbial book at him during sentencing, simply stating that there was nothing respectable about a high-ranking officer committing white-collar crime in an already corruption-rife society.

How then is it possible that the criminal record expungement debate has reared its head again, with the possibility of even further amendments to the law? In 2009, changes to sections 2 and 3 of the Criminal Procedure Amendment Act, allowed for the expungement of criminal records relating to certain criminal convictions. What this basically means is that if a person meets certain criteria, they can apply to have their name cleared. Any background checks performed on that individual in future will not show any trace of prior convictions.

One of the reasons cited for this change in the law at the time, was that it would be 'helpful' to people needing a clean record when applying for employment. Indeed, there are thousands of unemployed job applicants citing their criminal records as the reason for them not getting any job offers.

It seems contradictory to allow for more criminal record expungement while we deliver a rightfully heavy blow to those that lie on their CVs to get the jobs that they aren’t qualified for.

We live in a country where almost 600 000 learners who entered the schooling system 12 years ago, dropped out, leaving them without a matric certificate. Add to that figure, some research done by the Council of Higher Education (CHE), which shows that well over 40% of students end up dropping out of university.

So there are already hundreds of thousands of individuals who do not meet the criteria for the jobs they want, and you can put money on the fact that many of these individuals, will eventually, in desperation, pretend to hold those qualifications they never received in an effort to be employed.

If we’re terrified at the thought of an unqualified surgeon operating on our loved ones, we should be equally terrified of a convicted negligent driver behind the wheel of a 10-ton truck, or even a convicted rapist lurking in an office full of female co-workers.

Yes, these are extreme examples. But our question is this: How far will the criminal record expungement process go? How will we distinguish between people who have been rehabilitated by the justice system or not? No company needs the disastrous consequences of hiring a fraudster as a financial director, or the unimaginable, a sexual offender at an educational institution.

We are not saying that every single person with a criminal record is unemployable – not at all. There are thousands of excellent candidates around, who may have practiced poor judgement at some point in their lives which led to a criminal conviction. There are also thousands of people who have paid for their crimes, served their time, and have been successfully rehabilitated.

The point is this, an employer still has every right to be presented with all the facts before deciding if the candidate is the right choice for their organisation or not. A poorly thought out criminal record expungement process could have disastrous consequences. Let’s hope that this one gets handled carefully.



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Communication in any situation
Issue 8 2020, Elvey Security Technologies , Global Communications , Security Services & Risk Management
Global Communications offers an industry-first with five-year warranty on select Kenwood two-way radios.

Read more...
The year resilience paid off
Issue 8 2020 , Editor's Choice, Security Services & Risk Management
Hi-Tech Security Solutions spoke to Michael Davies about business continuity and resilience in a year when everything was put to the test.

Read more...
Factors affecting the success of criminal and disciplinary cases
Issue 9 2020 , Security Services & Risk Management
Sonja de Klerk discusses the factors that determine whether a criminal or disciplinary case can be successfully prosecuted or argued.

Read more...
Integration is key for smart city security
Issue 9 2020, Technews Publishing , Security Services & Risk Management
While smart cities are about enhancing the lives of people through smart technology, security is an essential aspect of success.

Read more...
Three mistakes when dealing with remote employees
Issue 9 2020 , Security Services & Risk Management
Sergey Ozhegov, CEO of SearchInform, says that employees are not the only weak points in the work-from-home chain.

Read more...
Looking back with a new perspective on the future
Issue 9 2020, Axis Communications SA , Editor's Choice, Security Services & Risk Management
Peter Lindström reflects on predictions he made about the macro trends affecting the sector in 2020 in the light of the pandemic.

Read more...
I want to be a Chief Risk Officer (said no one…. ever)
Issue 9 2020, Rectron , Security Services & Risk Management
With universal online access, a focus on going ‘paperless’ and the rise of the hybrid workforce due to COVID-19, the chief risk officer is more important than ever.

Read more...
Free-flow smart weapons detection system
Issue 8 2020, XPro Security Solutions , News, Security Services & Risk Management, Products
Detecting people carrying weapons and preventing them from entering your venue is now possible, without sacrificing the visitor experience.

Read more...
Meeting compliance obligations
Issue 7 2020 , Security Services & Risk Management
Helping businesses in SA understand and meet their compliance obligations to local regulations.

Read more...
Business continuity through a COVID-19 lens
Issue 8 2020 , Security Services & Risk Management
COVID-19 has brought business continuity under scrutiny, with the opportunity to enhance resilience into the future.

Read more...