Risky assessments

July 2012 Security Services & Risk Management

The risk assessment is a nebulous concept in our security industry. While it should be a process of discovering security vulnerabilities in your home or business and developing a plan to deal with them, it is more often than not simply seen a sales opportunity by security service providers.

The reason for this is that most people approach a security company and ask them to come in and tell them what they need. Andre Mundell, a director at Alwinco says this is the wrong approach.

“A security company will develop a risk assessment based on the products and services it sells,” says Mundell. “Hence the result is often more of a selection of what it sells, such as an alarm, PIRs and armed response services that are supplied without an SLA (service-level agreement), than a true analysis of what the client needs.”

Often, the result cost of the assessment is also tailored to what the security operator thinks the client can afford. A middle-class home will deal with the costs of installing an alarm and PIRs, but will generally not be keen to have cameras installed. In addition, the client will probably not know what options are available when it comes to an alarm and will let the security operator put in an alarm system it prefers.

Mundell says the solution recommended should ensure the client remains in control and not only the security service provider. “For example, an alarm system that sends an SMS message directly to the client as well as notifying the armed response unit is far more effective as it allows the client to warn his family or employees about the danger immediately. It should be a standard part of any alarm system, but is rarely recommended.”

Independent assessments

“When opting for an independent risk assessment, the client can be assured that the assessor has no financial stake in the final solution,” notes Mundell. “His job is to develop a solution that will secure the client, taking all the vulnerabilities in his environment into account.”

Once completed, the client can then choose to implement the complete plan, or, on his own responsibility, only implement part of the plan. In many instances, clients balk at the cost of a complete solution and are prepared to allow some vulnerabilities they consider less risky, while dealing with the more dangerous ones.

A proper risk assessment also guides the client in building a reliable security platform that can be expanded as required without creating more expense when certain elements of a standard security installation turn out to be incompatible with new additions. There is no reason a well-designed security plan should not allow for expansion and new products to be added over time. In fact, Mundell says the risk assessment should ensure that the client can adapt to changes in the security environment with ease.

Get what you need, not what you are given

Once the assessment is completed, the client should then approach the security service provider with a plan of what she wants. This leaves the client secure in the knowledge that the plan will actually deliver the security benefits required, not what a service provider wants to do with the products that happen to be in the storeroom.

From the security service provider’s perspective, Mundell says a proper, independent risk assessment will actually provide more income over time. Done properly the assessment will almost always recommend more than the standard installations these companies provide. And if the platform is installed correctly, the client can expand the services implemented over time.

“Perhaps the problem lies in the fact that security companies continually push their sales people to sell, looking for new clients and increased revenues,” says Mundell. “This leaves little time for ensuring each client gets a security installation that meets their needs; in fact it leaves no time to accurately understand what the client wants.

“It is also a result of clients not knowing what threats and solutions are out there, putting their trust in their service provider in the incorrect assumption that the operator will install a solution designed to solve her particular security problem.”

An independent risk assessor must focus on each client, providing solutions they need in their environment because that is their livelihood. If they are truly independent, they make no money from the products and services provided, only from ensuring their clients have a comprehensive risk assessment and security plan that works.

Says Mundell, “A security risk assessment is a realistic, thorough and intelligent approach to security as a preventative measure against crime. It gives a comprehensive mechanism that ultimately gives clients the compass of what they are up against in terms of security risk.”

In future issues, Alwinco will discuss the various aspects to include in a comprehensive risk assessment.





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Local manufacturing is still on the rise
Hissco Editor's Choice News & Events Security Services & Risk Management
HISSCO International, Africa's largest manufacturer of security X-ray products, has recently secured a multi-continental contract to supply over 55 baggage X-ray screening systems in 10 countries.

Read more...
Detecting humans within vehicles without opening the doors
Flow Systems News & Events Security Services & Risk Management
Flow Systems has introduced its new product, which detects humans trying to hide within a vehicle, truck, or container. Vehicles will be searched once they have stopped before one of Flow Systems' access control boom barriers.

Read more...
A standards-based, app approach to risk assessments
Security Services & Risk Management News & Events
[Sponsored] Risk-IO is web-based and designed to consolidate and guide risk managers through the whole risk process. In this article, SMART Security Solutions asks Zulu Consulting to tell us more about Risk-IO and how it came to be.

Read more...
Cybercriminals embracing AI
Information Security Security Services & Risk Management
Organisations of all sizes are exploring how artificial intelligence (AI) and generative AI, in particular, can benefit their businesses. While they are still figuring out how best to use AI, cybercriminals have fully embraced it.

Read more...
Integrate digital solutions to reduce carbon footprint
Facilities & Building Management Security Services & Risk Management
As increasing emphasis is placed on the global drive towards net zero carbon emissions, virtually every industry is being challenged to lower its carbon footprint and adopt sustainable practices.

Read more...
Visualise and mitigate cyber risks
Security Services & Risk Management
SecurityHQ announced its risk and incident management capabilities for the SHQ response platform. The SHQ Response Platform acts as the emergency room, and the risk centre provides the wellness hub for all cyber security monitoring and actions.

Read more...
Eighty percent of fraud fighters expect to deploy GenAI by 2025
Security Services & Risk Management
A global survey of anti-fraud pros by the ACFE and SAS reveals incredible GenAI enthusiasm, according to the latest anti-fraud tech study by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) and SAS, but past benchmarking studies suggest a more challenging reality.

Read more...
Deception technology crucial to unmasking data theft
Information Security Security Services & Risk Management
The ‘silent theft’ of data is an increasingly prevalent cyber threat to businesses, driving the ongoing leakage of personal information in the public domain through undetected attacks that cannot even be policed by data privacy legislation.

Read more...
Data security and privacy in global mobility
Security Services & Risk Management Information Security
Data security and privacy in today’s interconnected world is of paramount importance. In the realm of global mobility, where individuals and organisations traverse borders for various reasons, safeguarding sensitive information becomes an even more critical imperative.

Read more...
Proactive strategies against payment fraud
Financial (Industry) Security Services & Risk Management
Amid a spate of high-profile payment fraud cases in South Africa, the need for robust fraud payment prevention measures has never been more apparent, says Ryan Mer, CEO of eftsure Africa.

Read more...