Agentic AI: Building castles on quicksand?

SMART Surveillance 2025 AI & Data Analytics

Artificial Intelligence is in a strange spot. With the explosion of AI tools and applications, we are teetering between two inseparable yet intertwined paths – the promise of extraordinary capability and the peril of unmitigated risk. This precarious balance raises the question: Are we building something truly enduring, or are we rushing ahead on unstable foundations, building castles on quicksand?

Agentic AI covers a diverse range, from simple chatbots to the vision of fully autonomous systems that can act, reason, and take initiative. While the current hype often overshadows practical discussions, there is undeniable potential for rapid advances in this field. Agentic AI systems go beyond button-based conversational interfaces, offering tools that integrate into complex enterprise operations.

While the appeal is undeniable, a leap of this magnitude toward fully autonomous systems in enterprise-level applications could lead to unforeseen risks. While the threat of these risks remains a reality, we should instead focus on human-led Agentic AI – a level where intelligent tools enhance operations, while ensuring human oversight.


Ari Ramkilowan.


Stef Adonis.

Initiative and the ability to plan

The key distinction lies in initiative and the ability to plan. For example, an LLM is like an incredibly well-read librarian who can instantly recall and synthesise vast amounts of information from books. Ask this librarian a question, and they will provide a comprehensive, eloquent response, drawing from their extensive knowledge or the wealth of information at their disposal. If prompted, they might even respond as a pirate. They are exceptional at retrieving and combining information, but they always wait for your specific query.

On the other hand, an agentic application is like that same librarian, but instead of simply answering your question, they take it a step further by showing some initiative. They might say, “Based on what you are asking, I think you might also want to explore these related topics. I will go ahead and pull some additional resources, draft a preliminary research summary, and even reach out to some subject matter experts who might provide deeper insights.”

The agentic application introduces a layer of goal-oriented behaviour, breaking down complex tasks into sub-tasks, making decisions, and taking actions beyond mere information retrieval. It has the capacity to perceive an environment and take purposeful actions toward a specific goal rather than following a specific query or a predetermined sequence of events.

This holistic approach underlines its superiority to rigid, workflow-based tools that falter in handling edge cases.

The journey to autonomous agentic systems

While the journey toward fully autonomous agentic systems may still be on the horizon, enterprises are beginning to invest in the technology. The interest lies in faster iteration and broader scope, where agentic systems introduce flexibility without replacing existing workflows.

However, the promise of agentic AI comes with a great deal of risk, especially for businesses – misalignment of goals, unpredictable behaviour, loss of human oversight, amplification of bias, and security risks – all of which demand careful navigation.

So, we must ask ourselves not whether we can build this, but whether we should build this.

A hybrid path

There is a path forward that is more of a hybrid model – one that lies between structured processes and autonomous agents. This will give us the efficiency of agentic AI and the security of human involvement.

The allure of agentic AI is immense, but so are the responsibilities that come with it. Oversight, accountability, and ethical alignment must serve as the foundation of our innovation. These systems should enable autonomy within controlled parameters, minimising risks, while maximising potential.

As we look ahead, human-led Agentic AI may emerge as the ‘sweet spot’ – a balanced middle ground where technology supports rather than replaces human expertise.

The evolution of agentic AI is not just about technology, but deliberate and thoughtful integration. While the idea of fully autonomous systems tempts us with the promise of efficiency and innovation, it also demands vigilance. Building robust AI systems is not about surrendering control, but exercising it wisely.

So we do not need to build those castles on quicksand after all. We have the power to create a much firmer middle ground that combines the strengths of agentic AI and human expertise.

For more information, visit www.helm.africa




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

The impact of AI on security
Technews Publishing Information Security AI & Data Analytics
Today’s threat actors have moved away from signature-based attacks that legacy antivirus software can detect, to ‘living-off-the-land’ using legitimate system tools to move laterally through networks. This is where AI has a critical role to play.

Read more...
Who has access to your face?
Access Control & Identity Management Residential Estate (Industry) AI & Data Analytics
While you may be adjusting your privacy settings on social media or thinking twice about who is recording you at public events, the reality is that your facial features may be used in other contexts,

Read more...
Adding AI analytics to security monitoring
SEON South Africa News & Events Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection Residential Estate (Industry) AI & Data Analytics
SEON has announced its latest integration with Refraime, an AI-powered video analytics platform designed to elevate CCTV surveillance through real-time object detection and intelligent alerting.

Read more...
Making drone security more accessible
Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Residential Estate (Industry) AI & Data Analytics IoT & Automation
Michael Lever discusses advances in drone technology, focusing on cost reductions and the implementation of automated services, including beyond line of sight capabilities, for residential estates with SMART Security Solutions.

Read more...
Securing your estate beyond the gate
ATG Digital Access Control & Identity Management Residential Estate (Industry) AI & Data Analytics
Protecting gated communities and lifestyle estates requires a modern, intelligent approach. A truly intelligent system protects both physical and digital perimeters, it must be a fully integrated ecosystem.

Read more...
Make BIG and COMPLEX small and manageable
neaMetrics Suprema AI & Data Analytics Surveillance Integrated Solutions
Traditional CCTV and access systems often operate separately, creating gaps in visibility and efficiency. TRASSIR and Suprema have partnered to develop an integrated platform that improves security, operations, and situational awareness.

Read more...
Get the AI fundamentals right
Leaderware Editor's Choice Surveillance AI & Data Analytics
Much of the marketing for CCTV AI detection implies the client can just drop the AI into their existing systems and operations, and they will be detecting all criminals and be far more efficient when doing it.

Read more...
SMART Surveillance Conference in Johannesburg
Arteco Global Africa Technews Publishing SMART Security Solutions Axis Communications SA neaMetrics Editor's Choice Surveillance Security Services & Risk Management Logistics (Industry) AI & Data Analytics
SMART Security Solutions hosted its annual SMART Surveillance Conference in Johannesburg in July, welcoming several guests, sponsors, and speakers for an informative and enjoyable day examining the evolution of the surveillance market.

Read more...
The global generative AI market surpassed $130 billion in 2024
News & Events AI & Data Analytics
According to a new research report from the IoT analyst firm, Berg Insight, the Generative AI (GenAI) market grew substantially in 2024, experiencing triple-digit growth rates in all three major segments: GenAI hardware, foundation models, and development platforms.

Read more...
Questing for the quantum AI advantage
Infrastructure AI & Data Analytics
The clock is ticking down to the realisation of quantum AI and the sought-after ‘quantum advantage’. In many boardrooms, however, quantum remains mysterious; full of promise, but not fully understood.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.