Simplifying SIEM, EDR, XDR and SOAR

Issue 7 2022 Editor's Choice, Cyber Security

There is much hype around the SIEM, EDR, XDR and SOAR acronyms in the market today, and I think the frustration for most large enterprises is the contradictory information you find when searching for an explanation on the Internet. It is like trying to diagnose your own medical condition and getting scared out of your wits with the different ailments Google says you may have.

It’s ironic that when you search for these acronyms you get overloaded with information. You have to delve into it and try to make sense of it. Similarly, it is interesting that these acronyms exist because they have the data overload of cybersecurity events in common.

I have done my own investigation and have realised that many opinions are published based on a vendor, manufacturer or service provider furthering their own agenda. I believe a neutral perspective should be offered.

Why are these solutions important today? The best way to answer this is to go back 25 to 30 years. We hardly heard about an enterprise breach back then. When we did hear about an event it was big news. Today, it can still be big news, but it happens so regularly we have become immune to it.

There is an exponential rise in threats every year. Years ago it was a ‘script-kiddy’ wanting to prove he or she could gain access into an enterprise or government network. Today we are dealing with high-stakes, organised criminal activities by different types of bad actors with differing objectives. It is big business.

We also have to include ‘nation state’ attacks into the mix as there are countries that are providing funds to create cyber weapons. Some argue it is for defence reasons, but in war there is always collateral damage. This can be you or your organisation. Make no mistake, cyber war is happening all around us.

What is concerning is that there are more focused bad actors than there are focused defenders of our cyber environments. Attackers often use the very same tools initially designed to assess and defend our organisations’ environments for their malicious or criminal intentions. Enterprises use machine learning (ML) or artificial intelligence (AI) for defence, but bad actors are building the same capabilities into their attack tools. This, in turn, increases the complexity and the number of threats an enterprise is exposed to.

These are some of the cybersecurity challenges organisations experience today:

• Finding sufficiently skilled persons to defend or protect their environment.

• Log and alert overload giving rise to ‘alert fatigue’.

• The more stealthy threats may fly under the security team’s radar.

• Investigations take long, which takes up costly and scarce human resources.

• Disparate teams don’t always connect the dots when required.

• Too many false positives.

• Slow response to a threat, if any.

• Unnecessary compromise and business downtime.

What can organisations implement to help with these challenges?

• Add more skilled staff resources and more training.

• Correlate the detection of threats.

• Ensure faster analysis of events.

• Introduce better visibility in order to detect, identify and remediate threats faster.

• Identify stealthy threats automatically with machine learning.

• Automate detection, response and remediation.

Employing more staff may be possible for some organisations, but it has cost implications and there is the lack of available and qualified skills to consider. Automation is an option, hence the rise of SIEM, EDR, XDR and SOAR. There are more variations, but let’s keep it simple.

A neutral explanation of what each are:

• SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) has been around the longest. SIEM ingests data from multiple sources, helps correlate events and automates reporting in order for a human operator to analyse the result and make the next decision.

• EDR (Endpoint Detection and Response) is one of the first iterations of the era of automated response that you see in XDR and SOAR today. The endpoints are monitored for threats, threats are correlated and there is an automated response to a threat which may include remediation.

• XDR (Extended Detection and Response) we see as an extension or ‘extended’ detection and response where more data sources than just the endpoints are monitored and used for detection, response and remediation. These data sources can include SIEM, next-generation firewalls, endpoints and more.

• SOAR (Security Orchestration, Automation and Response) has much of the XDR functionality, but adds the automation of other security management processes like vulnerability management and playbooks into the solution in order to reduce the load on the security teams.

There are many conflicting definitions when researching these solutions. Many vendors like to refer to these solutions as software-as-a-service (SaaS), and this may be true in many instances, but it is possible to install comparative on-premises solutions or get the service from a managed service provider. There are obviously pros and cons to consider, dependent on your organisation’s requirements.

Organisations should carefully investigate what approach to take. It is worthwhile to consider the following:

• There will be a substantial cost to each solution, so investigate the differences between on-premises, SaaS or a managed service carefully over the long term.

• These are not ‘configure and leave’ solutions. Continuous improvement is required to manage them.

• Skilled people are still required to manage these solutions, whether you hire them or contract in a service provider.

• From a business perspective, the solutions should prevent attacks or a breach without business disruption or downtime.

• The intention is that critical applications, assets, personally identifiable information (PII) and organisational reputation are protected and maintained.

I hope that this short summary helps you make sense of the different solutions and their acronyms. Perhaps this can help you make a more informed decision about your cybersecurity defence systems.


Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Insights from the 2023 Cloud Security Report
News Cyber Security
Increased costs, compliance requirements, hybrid and multi-cloud complexities, reduced visibility, and a lack of skilled practitioners cause organisations to slow or adjust their cloud adoption strategies.

Read more...
New algorithm for OT cybersecurity risk management
Industrial (Industry) Cyber Security News Commercial (Industry)
OTORIO’s new risk management model and attack graph analysis algorithm technology, calculates OT cybersecurity threats and provides risk mitigation actions, prioritised according to actual exposure and potential impact on operations.

Read more...
Robots: a security opportunity or a threat?
Editor's Choice News Conferences & Events
Professor Martin Gill, Director of Perpetuity Research & Consultancy International and the School of Criminal Justice at the University of South Africa (UNISA), will be holding a Global Thought Leadership Security webinar on 22 June 2023 to discuss the contentious issue of robots operating in the security industry.

Read more...
UNISA sponsors Securex seminars
Editor's Choice News Conferences & Events
As part of UNISA’s 150-year birthday celebrations, UNISA has sponsored the Securex Theatre Seminar Programme, which will include a number of prominent industry specialists, academics and security practitioners focusing on a number of themes.

Read more...
Accenture Technology Vision 2023
Editor's Choice News
New report states that generative AI is expected to usher in a ‘bold new future’ for business, merging physical and digital worlds, transforming the way people work and live.

Read more...
Economists divided on global economic recovery
Editor's Choice News
Growth outlook has strengthened in all regions, but chief economists are divided on the likelihood of a global recession in 2023; experts are concerned about trade-off between managing inflation and maintaining financial stability, with 76% anticipating central banks to struggle to bring down inflation.

Read more...
Success in business process best practices
Technews Publishing Kleyn Change Management Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Security Services & Risk Management
This month we commandeer time with the woman who is spearheading our national conversation on Women in Security, Lesley-Anne Kleyn, to get to know the lady herself a little better.

Read more...
Addressing the SCADA in the room
Industrial (Industry) Cyber Security
Few other sectors command the breadth of purpose-built and custom devices necessary to function, as the industrial and manufacturing industries. These unique devices create an uncommon risk that must be assessed and understood to fully protect against incoming attacks.

Read more...
Vulnerabilities in industrial cellular routers’ cloud management platforms
Industrial (Industry) Cyber Security Security Services & Risk Management
Research from OTORIO, a provider of operational technology cyber and digital risk management solutions, unveils cyber risks in M2M protocols and asset registration that expose hundreds of thousands of devices and OT networks to attack

Read more...
SAFPS to launch a platform to combat fraud
Editor's Choice News Security Services & Risk Management
In response to the growing need for a proactive approach to fraud prevention, the SAFPS is developing a product called Yima, which will be a one-stop-shop for South Africans to report scams, secure their identity, and scan any website for vulnerabilities.

Read more...