Who watches the watchers?

October 2015 Surveillance, Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection, Integrated Solutions

For many businesses, security is a grudge purchase. Money gets thrown at solving a security issue, only to later discover holes that can only be plugged with more money. What’s more, the bolt-on services are generally very specific, meaning a bolt-on solution needs to be purchased for each and every hole in the system.

Gareth Cowan, OmniVision Security.
Gareth Cowan, OmniVision Security.

Before committing to any security solution, therefore, companies need to carefully consider, from the outset, what the strengths and weaknesses are of the available solutions, and choose those solutions that are most complementary. A very good example of complementary security solutions is onsite guarding paired with offsite, independent monitoring.

Many companies employ guards to watch over their assets. A guard can be an excellent deterrent, but being human, a guard is subject to issues such as self-preservation, self-interest, boredom and tiredness, with the result that most guards will generally do as little as is required to keep their job. For this reason, most guards cannot be left unsupervised for long periods.

But placing a second guard on-site to supervise the first doesn’t solve the problem, as the supervisor will be subjected to exactly the same temptations as the first. In an attempt to plug this security hole, tagging systems are installed, which act as an independent supervisor that ensures the guards perform the patrol they are contracted to perform. However, a tagging system does nothing to inform on what happens between patrols. The guards might be attentive and alert, or they might be having a 20 minute power-nap.

To solve this issue, many guarding companies now offer supervisory visits to their guarded sites. But this is generally limited to one visit per site, which often occurs around the same time each day or night and therefore becomes relatively predictable. Just like the criminal that waits for the guard to pass by before entering a premises, the guards themselves time their activities around the times they know a supervisor is due to visit. What’s more, these supervisory visits require the guarding company to employ an additional high-grade guard, purchase an additional car, and burn the petrol required to get the supervisor from site to site. At the end of the day, it’s the guarding companies’ clients who pay for all this.

Remote monitoring solution

A far more effective, and cost-effective, method of supervising guards is to do it via remotely monitored CCTV. Most companies using on-site guards also utilise a CCTV system for managerial purposes, which opens the opportunity up for monitoring of guards without any significant additional hardware spend on the part of the company. So there’s no upfront cost.

Also, the guarding company will no longer need to send a supervisor to all their sites each night. So there’s a potential reduction in the guarding fee.

An off-site monitoring station can schedule video check-ups on the guarding station at a frequency desired by the client at a very low incremental cost. So suddenly, hourly supervisory visits are possible, but more importantly, they are done stealthily: the guards do not know when they are being monitored. This raises the bar of ‘minimum effort’ from being attentive when the supervisor arrives to being attentive at all times.

However, just as guards require supervisors, the off-site monitoring company also requires systems in place to ensure its duties are carried out effectively. For the symbiotic relationship between guarding and monitoring to really produce results, the monitoring service needs to include a few key features.

Virtual guarding checks

Firstly, the site checks cannot be left to the discretion of the operator in the control room. Each and every supervisory visit must be scheduled in the monitoring station’s software to automatically present the required actions to the operator.

Secondly, the system must force that operator to carry out those actions without fail. Once an operator has begun processing a site check, they must be prevented from closing out the event before the correct cameras have been viewed for the correct amount of time – which has been predetermined and agreed to by the client.

Thirdly, to prove that the correct actions have been undertaken at the correct times, the monitoring station must also be able to produce a comprehensive audit trail that details each and every action the operator has taken, along with a time stamp for each action. All video viewed by the operator must be recorded off-site and must be viewable by the client on request. Ideally, the operator must also have the ability to broadcast audible announcements on-site, and these announcements must also be recorded and be made available to the client on request. In other words, the monitoring station must make itself fully accountable to the client.

An optimal security package is therefore one that combines the two complementary services of on-site guarding and professional, independent off-site monitoring. By ensuring that technology forms the final backstop of enforcement, where it is used to guide and ensure that the actions of operators are in compliance with the system as designed, the never-ending question of ‘who watches the watchers’ is put to rest and the security system as a whole delivers the expected results.

For more information contact Gareth Cowan, OmniVision Security, +27 (0)21 761 5336, gc@omnivisionsecurity.co.za, www.omnivisionsecurity.co.za



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Pentagon appointed as Milestone distributor
Elvey Security Technologies News & Events Surveillance
Milestone Systems appointed Pentagon Distribution (an Elvey Group company within the Hudaco Group of Companies) as a distributor. XProtect’s open architecture means no lock-in and the ability to customise the connected video solution that will accomplish the job.

Read more...
Empowering cities with intelligent security solutions
Secutel Technologies Surveillance IoT & Automation
By leveraging advanced AI analytics, real-time data collection, and seamless integration capabilities, cities can address pressing security challenges and create a safer environment for residents.

Read more...
Re-imagining business operations with the power of AI
AI & Data Analytics Surveillance
inq., a Convergence Partners company, has introduced a range of artificial intelligence (AI) solutions to assist organisations across industry verticals in optimising business operations and improving internal efficiencies.

Read more...
Eight MP dome for harsh environments
Axis Communications SA Surveillance Products & Solutions
Axis Communications announced a marine-grade stainless steel camera that offers performance in harsh environments. Enclosed in an electropolished stainless steel casing, it can withstand the corrosive effects of seawater and cleaning chemicals.

Read more...
Enhance control rooms with surveillance and intelligence
Leaderware Editor's Choice Surveillance Mining (Industry)
Dr Craig Donald advocates the use of intelligence and smart surveillance to assist control rooms in dealing with the challenges of the size and dispersed nature common in all mining environments.

Read more...
Future trends for electronic safety and security in mining
Fang Fences & Guards Mining (Industry) Integrated Solutions AI & Data Analytics
The mining industry is ever evolving, driven by technological advancements and the growing need for enhanced safety and security measures, with significant innovation seen in turnkey electronic security for mining operations.

Read more...
Unlocking enhanced security for mining
Mining (Industry) Integrated Solutions
In the dynamic landscape of African mining, security remains of paramount concern as threats evolve and challenges persist, and mining companies seek innovative solutions to safeguard their operations, assets, and personnel.

Read more...
A constant armed struggle
Technews Publishing XtraVision Editor's Choice Integrated Solutions Mining (Industry) IoT & Automation
SMART Security Solutions asked a few people involved in servicing mines to join us for a virtual round table and give us their insights into mine security today. A podcast of the discussion will be released shortly-stay tuned.

Read more...
Access and identity in 2024
Technews Publishing Gallagher HID Global IDEMIA Ideco Biometrics Enkulu Technologies neaMetrics Editor's Choice Access Control & Identity Management Integrated Solutions
SMART Security Solutions hosted a round table discussion with various players in the access and identity market, to find out what they experienced in the last year, as well as their expectations for 2024.

Read more...
Advanced security solution for high-risk areas
Secutel Technologies Surveillance Integrated Solutions
The need for a sophisticated intrusion detection system is paramount when faced with persistent security challenges, particularly in isolated battery rooms or high-risk areas prone to vandalism, cable theft, and battery theft.

Read more...